LIFE AND LETTERS
OF
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN
MACMILLAN AND CO., LIMITED
LONDON • BOMBAY • CALCUTTA MELBOURNE
THE MACMILLAN COMPANY
NEW YORK • BOSTON • CHICAGO ATLANTA • SAN FRANCISCO
THE MACMILLAN CO. OF CANADA, LTD.
TORONTO
ftvin fi
itactruUan
/>// (^.^..Aci'ln
LIFE AND LETTER
OF
JLEXANDER MACMILLAN
CHARLl
WITH PORTRAITS
MAC AN AND CO., LIMITED
ST. 3 STREET, LON1
1910
LIFE AND LETTERS
OF
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN
BY
CHARLES L. GRAVES
AUTHOR OF ' THE LIFE OF SIR GEORGE GROVE '
WITH PORTRAITS
u
MACMILLAN AND CO., LIMITED
ST. MARTIN'S STREET, LONDON
1910
z Jjff
PREFACE
WHEN Alexander Macmillan entrusted the task of writing a Memoir of his brother Daniel to Tom Hughes, he imposed conditions which practically involved his own self-effacement. Thus, in going through letters quoted in that Memoir, I have more than once come across affectionate or eulogistic references which were deliberately omitted in deference to these instructions. The reason for this self-denying ordi- nance, natural and creditable in Alexander Macmillan's lifetime, no longer exists, and it has been my en- deavour to exhibit the relations of the two brothers in truer perspective than was possible for Tom Hughes, as well as to indicate how loyally the younger carried on the traditions bequeathed him by the elder.
In the fulfilment of this aim, I have derived the greatest assistance from the volume of Alexander Macmillan's Letters edited by his son George for private circulation, and from the admirable- sketch of his father's life which is prefixed to that collection.
I also desire gratefully to acknowledge the valuable help lent me by Mrs. Alexander Macmillan, Mrs. Dyer, Mr. Robert Bowes, Mr. James MacLehose and Mr. and Mrs. Norman MacLehose, Mr. J. M. Ludlow, Mr. Aldis Wright, Sir Norman Lockyer, Mrs. J. R. Green, Miss Frances Martin, Mr. James Foster, and
PREFACE
Mr. Samuel R. Hutt, and to express my indebtedness to the advice and encouragement of Lord Morley of Blackburn.
My thanks are also due to Mr. J. W. Cross, Miss Rose Kingsley, Lady Grove, Mrs. J. R. Green, and Mrs. Tom Hughes for their kind permission to print letters from George Eliot, Charles Kingsley, George Grove, J. R. Green, and Tom Hughes.
C. L. G.
September^ 1910.
ILLUSTRATIONS
PAGE
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN - Frontispiece
From a Photograph by O. G. Rejlander, taken between 1860 and 1870.
KNAPDALE, UPPER TOOTING - - to face 199
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN - to face 371
Hon. M.A. Oxon., March 25, 1881.
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN - to face 377
From a Portrait painted in 1887, by Sir Hubert von Herkomer, R.A.
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN IN HIS LIBRARY AT
BRAMSHOTT CHASE - to face 385
Drawn by Lowes Dickinson, 1889.
LIFE AND LETTERS OF ALEXANDER MACMILLAN
I
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN was born at Irvine, in Ayr- shire, on October 3rd, 1818. The original seat of the Macmillan race, as he wrote himself in 1860, was Dunmore in Argyllshire, where a tongue of land known as North Knapdale seems formerly to have belonged to the clan, and inscriptions on the spot bear out this view. But somewhere about the end of the seventeenth or the beginning of the eighteenth century a branch of the Macmillan family migrated to the island of Arran. When Alexander Macmillan was spending his summer holidays in Arran in August, 1860, he saw a good deal of his aunt, Mrs. M'Kay, his father's sole surviving sister and widow of the Rev. Alexander M'Kay, for fifty years Independent minister of Glen Sannox, and from her he gleaned a good many curious details about his forbears. Some of these stories, which he regarded as semi-legendary, relate to the expulsion of "English soldiers" and marauders from Bute. Thus one tells how Edward Macmillan, having slain a Bute man, migrated with his brother Donald, their wives and families, to their ancestral home in Argyllshire, but
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1822
finally returned to Arran. Another story relates to a quarrel between the Macmillans and a neighbouring farmer, in which the Lord of Ranza, having been called in as arbitrator, intervened in their behalf because he was favourably impressed by the ferocity of the head of the Macmillan family. (His son had cut off the hand of a neighbour in a dispute about a rabbit which each claimed to have shot, and the father had boldly said that "had he been a true son of mine it would have been the head, not the hand.") Alexander Macmillan, in the journal in which he records these stories, expresses his regret that he had nothing more creditable to tell of his ancestors :
I am not proud of all these traditions, but as they are all I can get and there is a pleasure in realizing one's forefathers as flesh and blood — even though bloody — men, I put them down as I heard them from my aunt. . . . Of course all true Macmillans will hold the truth of them, and be proud of the deliverer of the island from English and Bute marauders. The first distinct historical person I can get at is my great-grandfather. His name was Daniel. He lived mostly in North Sannox, married a M'Kelvie, and had seven daughters and one son Malcolm born at Lochranza. Malcolm Macmillan married Janet Kerr of Lochranza, and lived at North Sannox till seven children had been born to him. He then moved to the "Cock" farm, where he lived for 30 years. Malcolm Macmillan had ten children, of whom the two eldest sons served on board the King's cutter in the Preventive service.
Alexander Macmillan did not remember his grand- father, who died in 1822, but he was held in high respect by his family and neighbours as a serious, upright, and, in spite of an austere manner, a kind- hearted man. Thus he was undemonstrative to his
i822] MALCOLM MACMILLAN
children, but would nurse them with great devotion when they were ill :
He would do acts of kindness quietly, and appear annoyed if they were remarked on — such as drawing home peats from the hill for poor people who had no horses of their own. . . . He was prudent, too, and prosperous in his limited way. I have been to the Cock Farm where he spent most of his life. The pre- sent tenant tells me that the land is so poor that he does not grow even the corn to make his own meal but buys it all. He keeps it exclusively for cattle and sheep. But my aunt says that when she was a girl they used to have "fine crops" of both barley and oats, and always had plenty for themselves besides selling a good deal. I daresay her idea of a fine crop would not satisfy a Lothian or a Cambridgeshire farmer. Still what was done must have been the result of great diligence and some skill.
Malcolm Macmillan, who was an elder of the Estab- lished Church, and devout and regular in family worship, looked with distrust on the revivalist movement pro- moted by James and Robert Haldane in the last years of the eighteenth century, though he allowed his children to attend the meetings of the missionaries sent to Arran. But on this point there is no mistaking the attitude of his grandson. Writing in 1860, he states his belief that he and all his family owe incalculable blessings to the revivals :
Whatever prosperity has come to us as a family is, in a great measure, owing to the effect they had on the moral, spiritual, and intellectual condition of my parents. The condition of the people, previous to their appearance, in morals and intellect at least, seems to have been exceedingly low. They were turbulent, superstitious, and otherwise degraded. . . . The belief in ghosts, brownies, and witchcraft was very prevalent. I remember my mother telling me
3
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1823
that there was a belief prevalent, even amongst the " godly," that evil spirits had actually haunted the island before the "coming of the gospel" — the Revivals— among the people, but they had all fled before its light. . . . The first impetus was given to the move- ment by a young minister from Bute, a simple earnest man with some eloquence, but apparently sober and quiet in his preaching. This "awakening" was not accompanied by any of the extravagances that have char- acterized later movements of a similar kind.
Of Malcolm Macmillan's children, Duncan, Alex- ander's father, born in 1766, was the sixth. He married Katherine Crawford, daughter of William Crawford, a fellow elder of his father, but, unlike him, a strong supporter of the Revivalists. Duncan Macmillan succeeded his father-in-law in the occupation of a small farm at Upper Corrie — "a most humble house on the brow of a hill overlooking the sea and getting, on fine days, a clear view of the Ayrshire coast" — where ten of his children were born, and in or about the year 1816 moved from Arran to Irvine in Ayrshire, where he died on July 24, 1823.
Mr. R. M. Hogg, the present headmaster of the Bank Street Public School in Irvine, writes :
There are none now living in our midst who re- member old Duncan Macmillan, but about 1896 there were some who had good recollections of him. He was exceptionally well spoken of, and seemed to have been what we would now call a " crofter," that is to say, kept a few cows, pastured on the burgh moor, and cultivated a few acres of the town's land. At other times he was a carter — mainly engaged carrying coal from the neigh- bouring pits to the harbour of Irvine. Like the Pied Piper he seemed to have a special attraction for the young, and in all these recollections each had the same story to tell — that his cart, when returning or leaving
4
1823] DEBT TO HIS PARENTS
light, was always filled with children happy to enjoy a ' ' hurl." He appears to have been a very earnest-minded man, deeply religious and on very friendly terms with the Rev. Mr. Barclay, the pastor of the Baptists in Irvine, then a very strong body.
Alexander Macmillan was not five years old when his father died, but he shared his brother Daniel's reverence for his memory. " He was a hard-working man, a most devout man, and, as I have heard mother say, cared for nothing but his family, that is, did not care what toil he endured for their sakes." l How hard the struggle was is made clear, though in no complaining spirit, by other letters from the same hand. Four of his daughters were carried off in childhood by an epidemic in 1813, and there is little doubt that his own life was shortened by his unremitting exertions. But if his children owed much to his example, they owed still more to the deep and abiding influence of their mother. Daniel's affection was expressed shortly before her death with vehement fervour. It was his persuasion that his mother was ' ' the most perfect lady in all Scotland " :
With so little knowledge derived from books, with so very little intercourse with the higher ranks of society, with so little care or thought on what is most pleasing in external conduct, was there ever a lady who so instinctively, so naturally, did what was right, acted with so much propriety in all cases ? She has such high and noble notions that no one ever heard her say, or knew her do, a mean thing, no one could even venture to say an impudent thing to her, or talk scandal in her presence. . . . No one could be more deeply religious than she is and yet how little she talks about it! . . . The end of the whole matter is, that I think there is
1 Letter from Daniel Macmillan to his brother Malcolm, June 1 5, 1833. Memoir of Daniel Macmillan, by Thomas Hughes, p. 18.
5
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1816
nobody like mother in the whole world. If ever I saw any one with the same tenderness, strength, and calmness, the same joyousness of heart, with the same depth, I should instantly fall in love with her, that is if there was any chance of its ever coming to any- thing! ... I tell you I am proud of my parentage. . . . Besides, I am very glad that my mother is a Teuton. [Her father was a lowlander by descent, whose ancestors had come from Renfrewshire.] From her we take any mental superiority we may have.1
That Alexander Macmillan shared these feelings we know from constant references, and the lapse of time did not blunt or abate their strength. Writing twenty years after her death to his brother Daniel, Alexander Macmillan says :
I don't know if it has occurred to you that my dear new boy came into the world the same day that twenty years ago our dear sainted mother died. I find on reference that it was on the first of August, 1835, that she died. Is it Popish to say may her spirit watch over him ? I think it is at least a good and wholesome feeling to believe that she will. I feel perfectly sure that many a time I have been saved doing and thinking wrong by the consciousness of her presence.
So in a letter to M. Guizot in June, 1867, he says:
My mother was a woman of very devout nature and habits, whose daily life was, as I believe, lived as in the conscious presence of God. She had a very noble, sweet nature, and a certain serenity and clearness of mind that I have hardly ever met with in any other human being.
Not the least remarkable fact about this admirable woman was that, in spite of the ceaseless burden of
1 Letter from Daniel Macmillan to his brother Malcolm, June 15. 1833. Memoir of Daniel Macmillan^ pp. 1 9-20.
6
1816] MOTHER AND BROTHERS
household work, she found time to read, and to read the great books. There is a story of a visitor calling upon her in her old age at Irvine and finding her in bed in her black "mutch" reading Gary's Dante. She sang ballads and hymns with a pathos which made the promise of a song the reward which had most weight with her sons.1 But above all she influenced them in the direction of a generous toleration — an inheritance from her own father :
Without any speculative liberality she had a remark- able openness of mind, which expressed itself in such phrases as "puir body, he has nae room in him," when she heard over-zealous persons speaking bitterly of opponents ; or when, to the scandal of many in Irvine, she stated that to her thinking such of them as had the good fortune to reach heaven would have to put up with the company of many Romanists.2
When Duncan Macmillan migrated to Irvine, his two elder sons were already established there as carpenters, but both took to teaching, and Malcolm was master of a school when his father's death made him head of the family. Of Malcolm Macmillan, who was nearly twenty years older than himself, Alexander always spoke with reverence and gratitude. ' ' He had many of the charac- teristics of my mother, in particular he was a man of the same consistent piety" (Letter to M. Guizot quoted above). Out of his small salary he contributed to the support of his mother and the education of his brothers and sisters, but there was never any chance of sending either Daniel or Alexander to a University ; neither of them got more than a primary school education, and while Daniel was apprenticed to a bookbinder before he was eleven, Alexander was headmaster of Scott's
libid. p. 8. *ibi<t. p. 8.
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1830
School in Irvine at the age of sixteen. Of his school days at the Irvine Academy he gives some interesting reminiscences in a letter to his old school-fellow Speirs, written in October, 1870. His family, he mentions, was so poor that even the very moderate school-fee that was charged at the Academy was a matter of considera- tion to them. It was only a High School, and the headmaster, "though an assiduous teacher, was wholly lacking in skill or manliness to draw out the gifts or strengthen the moral tone of his pupils." But Connel, the master of the Commercial Department, was a man of a fine intellect and high character, and a firm dis- ciplinarian :
I think I was only three months with him, and the impression he made on me was such that even now, when I know most of the headmasters of the great public schools of England, as personal friends more or less, I am constantly thinking and comparing them with Connel. You remember he went to the High School at Glasgow afterwards. What a lesson it is in his life to think how great is the influence unseen and unnoted at the time, a man intent on doing his work simply, unselfishly, manfully, may have on the future of any man's life. I owe much to his memory. I think he was a common hand-loom weaver in early life, and taught himself most of what he knew. And yet he was a perfect gentleman, courteous, high-toned, simple, really noble, and with what keen intellect!
Alexander Macmillan goes on to say that his impres- sion was confirmed at Cambridge many years afterwards when it was suggested that their firm should publish a new edition of Connel's book on the Differential Calculus. He consulted several high mathematical authorities, who unanimously declared that, in view of the author's origin and defective education, it was a masterly work.
8
1830] IRVINE ACADEMY
Connel "was also an enthusiastic student of nature, and seems to have kindled in his pupils a love for outdoor studies. Along with the first Dr. Landsborough he founded an Ayrshire County Naturalist Club." The teaching was not only good, but there was a fine demo- cratic spirit about the school. "In those old days," writes Mr. Hogg, " it was no uncommon thing for the laird's son to sit on the same bench with the cottar's son, e.g. Lord Eglinton's son attended the Grammar School in Irvine."
Of his school experiences out of school hours he has left an account in the same letter :
I remember a great " stane-battle " with Scott's School in which I think you were one of the leaders. I remember, too, great snowball fights, in which you and David and John Watt were among our champions, with the town-end weavers.1 I remember, also, one some- what riotous and irregular affair, when you and David Watt and I went down to the shore to " dook," and varied our walk along the Halfway by shutting all the " window-brodds " as we went along, to the disturbance of the auld wives who rushed out to see what was up. I was reminding David Watt whom I see now and then here, of this affair, and charging him with being the leader, which with his native modesty, he repudiated, so it may have been you after all.
Other contemporaries were Johnston, called ' ' Butter- fly," whom he met twenty years later transformed into
1Mr. R. M. Hogg writes in December, 1909 : "Mr. Alexander Longmuir of Roseholm remembers the snow battle Alex. Macmillan speaks of in his letter to Speirs. The Academy stands on the edge of the moor, and at mid-day the town-end weavers were wont to go past the school to the moor for a quiet smoke. The boys — many of them sailors' sons — were somewhat wild, and, it must be owned, impudent, and the weavers had to stand considerable annoyance. The result of the great snow fight was that the weavers were fined — most unjustly in old Mr. Longmuir's opinion."
9
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1831-
a big burly man, and who became a prosperous merchant in America ; Robert Buchanan, afterwards a shipbroker in London ; Willie Boyd, the Antinous of the school, good at figures as well as games, whose subsequent career, in the wood trade in Newfoundland, hardly fulfilled the romantic promise of his youth ; and Speirs, to whom he addressed this letter. Though never dis- tinguished in games or interested in sport, Alexander Macmillan took his part, as we have already seen, in the rough-and-tumble of schoolboy life, and a story which appeared in a Scotch newspaper shows that he was by no means wanting in pluck. Like the other boys at the Academy, he learned to swim in the Annick, and when one of his schoolmates challenged him to throw a somer- sault into the river — a feat he had never attempted before — and, on his hesitating, said jeeringly, "You're frichtit ; you're a coward," ' ' Sanny " hotly replied, "That was never telt of a Macmillan yet," and hurled himself into the river with such violence that he knocked all the wind out of his body and had to be brought ashore by some of the elder boys.
Of the half-dozen years that elapsed between his leaving school and joining his brother Daniel in London the records are few and the dates hard to fix. He tells Speirs in the letter already quoted that he was headmaster of Scott's School for three months when he was of the mature age of fifteen or sixteen. This, Mr. Hogg tells me, was a small school, connected with the Burgher Kirk, in the East Back Road opposite the Pen Close, and within a stone's throw of the old homestead of the Macmillans. Scott, who succeeded Montgomerie, the first headmaster, was a native of Perth, and afterwards minister of Loreburn United Presbyterian Church, Dum- fries, and was probably finishing his Divinity course at
10
1833] GEORGE GALLIE
the University when Alexander Macmillan took his place. But there seems to be no doubt from a letter to James MacLehose in November 22, 1881, that Alexander Mac- millan's first start in the world outside Irvine was as an assistant to Mr. George Gallic, the well known Glasgow bookseller, an old-fashioned Scotsman, to whom James MacLehose was apprenticed, and with whom he stayed till 1833. Towards the end of this period, from 1831 onwards, Daniel Macmillan was acting as assistant to Mr. Atkinson, a bookseller in the Trongate, not far from Mr. Gallic's shop, and it was in this way that the two young men got to know each other and the family friend- ship began which was destined to be drawn still closer by marriage ties in the next generation. Of George Gallic there is an excellent picture in a note to the notice of James MacLehose in One Hundred Glasgow Men :
George Gallic's shop was first in Brunswick Place, then in Glassford Street, and finally in Buchanan Street. . . . Thomas MacLehose could not have sent his boy to a better school for honesty, industry and thorough- ness, nor to a worse school for manners. Gallie was a " kenspeckle" character, at bottom a man of rare virtue, true and tried, at top undoubtedly trying. A man of few words he gave you an answer at the time and in the way that pleased him. ... A man of clear-cut opinions and high principle, he would not budge an inch for any man or number of men. He was a Voluntary, and on the day of a public fast for the cholera, when weak-kneed or puzzle-headed brethren followed the multitude to church, Gallie, it was said, opened his shop at six in the morning. He dealt mostly in tracts and religious books. Nothing would have tempted him to keep literature that he disapproved of. It was a favourite joke of young scamps to ask him for Punch. Punch — he would have kicked it on to the pavement, as he was said to have actually done to an obnoxious packet.
ii
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN Ll820'
In view of Gallic's austere literary judgment one is not surprised to learn that Alexander Macmillan's stay under his roof was of short duration :
My leaving dear George Gallic arose from his piety — in excess. He objected to my reading novels, and one day found a volume of The Midnight Ball, I think — but at least one of the Minerva Press novels — in the pocket of my overcoat, which was hanging up in the passage. He pulled it out, tore it to pieces and flung it into the fire. Of course there was a scene, and hence the separation. But it turned out really a blessing. William, whose Shewalton School was the house-feeding element at the time, within a few months after my return — I had in the meantime been at the Irvine Academy, where I got my instruction in Classics in return for helping Stewart with his junior class — had a severe illness and was obliged to be away for three months, during which I took his school and hence was the support or the house for that time. . . . Daniel was then in Cambridge and probably hardly realised or knew what was going on.
Shewalton colliery and school were situated in the parish of Dundonald, quite close to Irvine. The district comprises a long series of sandhills, which, when swept by winter storms, reveal numerous neolithic relics. Mr. R. M. Hogg, whose local knowledge has been most helpful to me in dealing with this period of Alexander Macmillan's life, has contributed some interesting notes on the Shewalton episode :
In the recently published history of Glasgow Uni- versity it is noted that during the prevalence of plague (1645-7) part of the classes under Professor Dickson— former minister of Irvine — removed to Irvine and carried on the work there. Dickson speaks of the happy walks and talks he had with his students amongst the yellow sandhills of Irvine, i.e. along by Shewalton. It is
12
1834] SHE WALTON SCHOOL
interesting to think of Alexander Macmillan nearly two centuries later teaching the little school amongst the same yellow sandhills. About 1820 the pits at Shewalton were leased to a Mr. John Samson, salt manufacturer, from Troon, who was associated with Mr. Benjamin Rowe, merchant in Irvine. Around the pits sprang up a little community of miners — living in very primitive houses — "tour houses," i.e. turf houses or clay-biggings. At the period of greatest prosperity there would be a population of 300 at the most. The first school built by the Samsons was as rude in construction as the miners' dwellings — turf or clay wall and a thatched roof. There were three long benches arranged around the three sides of the room, and the pupils faced the fire. There is still living at Kilwinning a nonagenarian, Mr. Thomas Ballantyne (aged 94), who was born and brought up at Shewalton. He remembers the school perfectly well. The only teacher he remembers is a Mr. Caldwell, who was, as the custom then was, a Divinity student, who taught during the summer months, going to College in the winter season, when he provided a substitute. Alexander Macmillan was probably a winter substitute. There was a night school in connection with the works, and old Ballantyne remembers attending it as a young man. He has a vivid recollection of the place at night. Each man carried a candle, which he stood on the desk in front of him. The subjects were the three R's, and he recalls the time spent by the master preparing the old-time quill pens. The teacher taught a Sunday school and held a religious service on the Sunday evening for the benefit of the miners.
Ballantyne has no special remembrance of Alexander Macmillan, but an old woman still resides at Drybridge, about a quarter of a mile from the Shewalton pits, who was born at Shewalton and distinctly remembers Alexander teaching a winter term at Shewalton old school. Mr. Samson, the lessee of the pits, resided for a time at Shewalton, and his sons, Alexander and James, both attended the school for a time previous to entering
13
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1835
the Academy. A. M. Samson died 9th November, 1900, aged 77 ; and James Samson died 24th February, 1907, aged 85. James was a man of literary tastes, and he used often to speak in enthusiastic terms of how young Macmillan tried at Shewalton to give his older pupils an understanding of the spirit of poetry. The recollection of these lessons remained with him all his days. An attempt was also made to interest the pupils in botany, through the names of common wayside plants — probably due to Dr. Connel's influence.
The old school was replaced by a stone structure, which, when the pits were abandoned — 1846 — was converted into two dwelling-houses, and is still used for that purpose.
Alexander Macmillan's next appointment was as assistant in a Commercial School in Glasgow, where the late Dr. Alexander Maclaren of Manchester was one of his pupils.
" He vainly endeavoured," writes Dr. Maclaren, " to teach me to write as well as he did, somewhere about the years 1834 to 1835 m classes f°r 'writing and arithmetic' in Glasgow, of which the principal was Duncan M'Dougall. All that I remember was his occasional marching up and down between the rows of desks with a cane over his shoulder and stopping now and then to look over a slate or set a sum or ' mend a pen.'"
To this period probably belong what his son calls his spasmodic efforts to enter two widely different pro- fessions, the medical and the nautical." At one time he acted as assistant in a chemist's shop in Glasgow, and thus acquired a considerable knowledge of drugs. Indeed, there is a family story of his experimenting on two boys with chloroform, then a new drug, with results that for the moment were alarming : " he had them deid
14
1836] VOYAGE TO AMERICA
on the floor" was the comment of an old friend of the family. More romantic than this excursion among the gallipots was a voyage to America before the mast in September, 1836. This adventure, which was doubt- less prompted by discontent or rebellion against his straitened circumstances, was never repeated and seldom referred to. Only once or twice in the letters extending over a period of forty years have I noted a nautical metaphor,1 and, in his letter to Speirs, he speaks of his "somewhat foolish attempt at being a sailor," after which he was stranded in Glasgow absolutely penniless :
I went about the streets of Glasgow looking out for any sort of employment and finally accepted, with the deepest joy, an ushership in a school with the munificent salary of £12 a year, on which I actually lived for nine months. I had a good many really kind friends, who were willing and anxious to help me. I don't think they could do more than they did, and that in the way of help to a situation was — nothing. I found this myself, and I fancy on the whole it was a good thing. I was then light-hearted, I suppose what the English call plucky. I went at the job I got, did it as well as I could, and so got on. It chanced to be in my line. If I had been offered a good porter's place at 6s. a week I would have taken it, but I don't think it would have suited me so well. Still I think I would have done it as well as I could.
Only that he speaks explicitly in a letter to James MacLehose (April 20, 1865) of living for nine months on 55. a week in Glasgow, we should be inclined to identify this ushership with his post at Nitshill, near
1 E.g. where he speaks of a friend "sitting . . . with a huge meerschaum in his mouth and his face shining like a nor'-west moon in a cloud." Letter to his brother Daniel, Sept. 17, 1850.
15
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1833
Paisley, in Renfrewshire, where in 1838-9 he had under his care 130 rough colliery children, many of them Irish, and all of the poorest. The work that fell to him was rudimentary and ''most drudgical," and it was sometimes a hard task for the young schoolmaster to keep control over his pupils. His sister Janet kept house for him and a small sewing-school to increase their income, but they found it hard to make both ends meet. Of his ability as a teacher it is hard to judge. The letter from which we have quoted indicates a certain consciousness of aptitude for the work ; none the less he was sincerely grateful to his brother for rescuing him from what by his own admission was a pinched and struggling life. "Had it not been for your brotherly sympathy and help, I should certainly to this day have been a wretched and not too useful dominie at best." l Alexander Macmillan speaks of the failure of his friends to find him a situation in 1837, but he is very far from imputing to them any lack of good-will. Indeed, throughout his career he was never guilty of a failure to acknowledge his indebtedness to his friends and patrons. Mention has already been made of the MacLehoses of Glasgow, but at this stage of his career an even closer bond attached him to the Wilsons of Edinburgh. The friendship between the families dates back to about the year 1830, the connecting link being probably Mr. Maxwell Dick, the bookseller and bookbinder of Irvine, to whom Daniel Macmillan had been apprenticed in 1824, and who was a friend of Mr. Wilson, a wine merchant in Edinburgh. Any- how by 1833 we find Daniel, in the already-quoted eulogy of his mother, saying that in the matter of deep religious feeling Mrs. Wilson, of Edinburgh, came
1 Letter to his brother Daniel, August 30, 1855. 16
1 833] GEORGE WILSON
nearest to her, and the veneration with which the brothers regarded her thenceforth was almost filial in its intensity. Her nobility of character and rare natural gifts were transmitted in full measure to her son George, Daniel's contemporary, and their friendship, as Mr. Hughes notes, was strengthened by the pathetic similarity of their careers: "in each case a noble life-long struggle for the fulfilment of life-work against fatal disease." In the phrase of one of his friends, George Wilson was "a splendid jewel in a shattered casket." Half his life was spent in sickness or positive torture — he was con- stantly being blistered or cauterised or mutilated by the knife. Yet crippled as he was by the amputation of a foot, racked with rheumatism and enfeebled by repeated haemorrhages, living too " in a house full of invalids with the shadow of the grave always hanging over it," he preserved an unconquerable gaiety of heart, and crowded into his brief life an astonishing amount of work as student, teacher and writer. It was written of him that he always worked as though his days were numbered, and he left on record the noble saying, ' ' to none is life so sweet as to those who have lost all fear to die." George Wilson, who was born five years after Daniel Macmillan, and died two years later, was at the time of his death Professor of Technology in the University of Edinburgh and Director of the Industrial Museum of Scotland. His elder brother Daniel, afterwards Sir Daniel Wilson, became Professor of History and English Literature in Toronto University in 1853, succeeded to the Presidentship in 1881, and died in 1892, having outlived his brother by thirty-three years. Alexander Macmillan in later life spoke of Daniel Wilson as his oldest friend, but his feeling for his brother was some- thing quite apart and peculiar. Indeed it is not too B 17
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1837
much to say that George Wilson1 is to be reckoned amongst the half-dozen men whose example and character exerted a deep and indelible influence on the subject of this Memoir.
To explain the circumstances which led to Alexander Macmillan's emancipation from the drudgery of school- mastering, it is necessary to retrace our steps and follow the career of his brother Daniel. After seven years spent as apprentice to Maxwell Dick in Irvine, Daniel had filled engagements as bookseller's assistant first in Stirling then in Glasgow. His health, never strong, gave way in 1833, and after a serious illness he decided to move southward. Armed with introductions from his employer he proceeded to London in September, 1833, put up with James MacLehose, who was then with Messrs. Seeley in Fleet Street, and ultimately got a job as assistant to a Mr. Johnson in Cambridge at a salary of £30 a year. The three years which he spent at Cam- bridge, though saddened by the death of his mother, were of the greatest possible service to him in the way of building up a connexion. Reading men of all ages were naturally attracted by this intellectual young Scots- man, who had not only a thorough mastery of every branch of the business of the book trade, but knew a great deal about the insides of the books that were worth knowing. In January, 1837, he left Cambridge and went to Scotland for a short holiday, prolonged to three months by another serious illness, during which he was nursed by Mrs. Wilson as if he had been ' ' her own and only son." In March he was again on the look out for a job, and had actually closed with a Leith stationer for
1 See Memoir by his sister Jessie Aitken Wilson, Edinburgh : Edmonston & Douglas, 1860 ; the essay on him by Dr. John Brown in Horae Subsechae^ second series ; and Dr. John Cairns's in memoriam notice in fMacmillarfs {Magazine, January, 1860.
18
1839] ENGAGED BY SEELEY'S
£$o a year, when, through MacLehose, there came the offer of a situation in Messrs. Seeley's shop. His Leith employer goodnaturedly released him from his engage- ment, and in two years he had established such excellent relations with Messrs. Seeley that when a vacancy occurred in the autumn of 1839, they readily undertook, on his recommendation, to engage his brother Alexander at £60 a year as a collector. Daniel wrote for him at once, and Alexander arrived on October 3, 1839, his twenty-first birthday. From that day — apart from occasional absences owing to ill-health — the two brothers were never separated until Daniel's death in 1857.
Reviewing this period of Alexander Macmillan's life one realises how meagre was his stock of learning when he entered on the business of his life. His schooling ended when he was fifteen ; the smattering of classics which he got in return for assisting the headmaster of the Irvine Academy might fairly be summed up in the phrase, * ' Little Latin and less Greek " ; and of French or German he never had the chance of learning a word. Forced to earn his living at fifteen he had little time for reading — the only way of continuing his education — while he was employed on the "most drudgical" kind of schoolmastering. But the habit of reading was there, coupled with an inherited appreciation of great literature, and in his own words, "when a series of those strange sequences of events which our pious forefathers devoutly, and, as I think wisely, called providences of God, led me into dealing in books, there can be little doubt I was led into the line for which my natural gifts fitted me." Though far less widely read than his brother at this age, he had seen more of human nature and had been brought into closer contact with the world of action. Again, his four or five years' schoolmastering was in many ways
19
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1839-
an excellent preparation for one who was to deal so largely in educational publications. Having himself taught beginners, he was an excellent judge of essentials in school manuals. But the experiences of these early years, if they afforded him scant opportunities for enriching his intellect, were potent in building and strengthening his character, and enlarging his sympa- thies. The splendid example of his father, his mother and his three elder brothers inspired him with an ineradicable belief in the sacredness of the family tie and the binding obligations of family responsibility. He had known the pinch of poverty, but it had not crushed his spirit or embittered his heart. And lastly, though poor in this world's goods, he was already rich in friendships which were only endeared by his absence in the South. George Wilson was one of the very first persons whom he invited to contribute to his Magazine on its foundation twenty years later, and his constant reliance on the judgment of James MacLehose is attested by a correspondence continuously maintained for thirty years.
20
1 843] EARLY DAYS IN LONDON
II
WHEN Alexander Macmillan came to London in October, 1839, he lodged with his brother at a boarding-house in Hoxton kept by the Misses Nutter. A month later Daniel brought up his sister Janet and a niece from Glasgow, and in March, 1840, they moved into unfur- nished apartments at 26 Bartlett's Buildings. The ex- periment proved a failure. Janet's health broke down, and Daniel was so embarrassed that he sold the library of favourite books he had been collecting all his life to clear himself of debt and pay doctors' bills and the cost of bringing his sister and niece to London. Janet Mac- millan returned to Scotland and the brothers moved to a boarding-house in 8 Charterhouse Square, which was their headquarters until they migrated to Cambridge in 1843.
Alexander Macmillan soon found his feet at Seeley's, and satisfied not only his employers, but his brother, who had a high standard. Mr. Burnside, one of the partners, proved a generous friend to the brothers, and Daniel alludes to the hospitalities of his son William as " a saving to us which is of consequence to such poor chaps." By 1840 Alexander's salary had been raised to ;£8o a year, and early in 1843 tne two brothers started a small bookshop on their own account at 57 Aldersgate Street. To the former year also belongs Alexander Macmillan's first venture in authorship. Mention has already been made of his love of poetry, but in view of his antecedents it is somewhat of a surprise to learn that Shelley was one of his earliest heroes. The fruits of
21
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1840
this admiration took the form of a little 321110 volume of selections entitled, The Genius of Shelley, prefaced by a sketch of his life founded on the Shelley Papers, Leigh Hunt's Byron and his Contemporaries, Lander's Imaginary Conversations, and an article in the New Monthly Magazine of 1832. It was published anony- mously by George Bell at the close of 1 840, and the secret was so well kept that his own son never knew for certain of his father's share in the book until nearly seventy years after its publication. The selection is interesting not merely as the first that was made of Shelley's works, but from the principle of selection adopted. Most of the famous lyrics are there — " To the Skylark," the lines "To Night," " Mutability," and the " Ode to the West Wind," but there are fragments from "Adonais" and other poems, and excerpts from "The Cenci," " Hellas," and ' ' Prometheus Unbound." By way of preface there is an " advertisement " which concludes with the remark : ' To those who are so young as to run any risk, in reading the strange, crude, and even false opinions to be found in his [Shelley's] works, the present Selection may be safely recommended."
These years in London were marked by loss and gain in other than material ways. In March, 1838, Alexander's elder brother William died suddenly at the Rawdon Baptist College at Bradford, where he had entered as a student, and in February, 1840, Malcolm, on whom Daniel and Alexander had so long looked as a second father, died at Stirling after a long illness. But he found consolation for these bereavements in the comradeship of his brother Daniel and in contact with such stimulat- ing personalities as Carlyle, whose lectures on Rousseau, Johnson and Burns he attended in 1840, and Hone, the compiler of Hone's Every Day Book and the uncom-
22
1842] "GUESSES AT TRUTH"
promising champion of a free press. To the works of Carlyle he had been introduced by Daniel shortly after his arrival in London. '* Alexander," wrote Daniel to George Wilson in November, 1839, "nas to get UP at six to be in Fleet Street at eight. While he is dressing and breakfasting I read some book to him — just now it is Sartor Resartus" Hone at this time was sub-editing the Patriot, a prominent Dissenting organ, and as a customer at Seeley's shop struck up a friendship with Alexander, which led to his occasionally visiting the brothers at Bartlett's Buildings. Hone, like them, was a member of Dr. Binney's congregation at the Weigh House Chapel, and the mention of Dr. Binney brings us to what was undoubtedly the most important, fruitful and far-reaching of all the influences which affected Alexander Macmillan during these early years in London. When Daniel Macmillan was at Cambridge he joined the Baptist community in December, 1833, and on his return to London attended Dr. Binney's services until 1842. But in the autumn of 1840 he read Guesses at Truth by Two Brothers, which, in his own words, "introduced me to a quite new region." He not only read and talked it over with Alexander in their walks in London Fields, the untenanted space which then stretched away to the north east, but was moved to write a letter on the condition of young men in London to the anonymous authors. The correspond- ence was renewed in June, 1 842, when Daniel forwarded some tracts by Alexander Scott, the friend of Edward Irving, to Archdeacon Hare. In his reply Hare men- tioned Maurice's work on The Kingdom of Christ, and invited his correspondent down to Hurstmonceaux, where Daniel spent three memorable days in September, 1842. Hurstmonceaux appealed to Daniel Macmillan
23
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1842
because it was crammed with books — Maurice thought it was the best private library in England — and the mingled urbanity, learning, tolerance and goodness of his host proved irresistible. Their talk was largely of men of letters — Wordsworth and Coleridge, De Quincey, Landor (a recent visitor) and Charles Lamb. But they also freely discussed religious matters, and Daniel Macmillan found himself in entire agreement with Hare's " strong and rational objections to the condi- tions and principles of Dissenters. It is needless to say that they are quite free from all narrowness, bigotry, malice, hatred and ignorance. I wish we had a host of such men as Hare and Maurice. I think the contradic- tions of Protestantism would get reconciled ; and if that were the case, perhaps we might hope to see Popery or Romanism cease to be Papist and Romanist and become really Catholic." On his return to town Daniel Macmillan at once wrote at length to Dr. Binney to explain the reasons which had determined him never to attend the Weigh House Chapel again. The letter, as his biographer remarks, shows a certain embarrassment and some morbid feeling, but the real motives of his secession are none the less perfectly clear. The services of the Church of England appealed to him far more powerfully than those of the Baptist community, and the repugnance against Dissent, which had been growing on him for some years, had been brought to a head by Maurice's Kingdom of Christ, of which he wrote to his old schoolfellow Watt, then a missionary in India, "I found it to be a book that I could not live without." From that day onward the influence of Hare and Maurice on both brothers steadily grew — we have good reason to assume that Alexander seceded from the Weigh House Chapel at the same time as Daniel — but their
1 843] ARCHDEACON HARE'S HELP
personal reverence and affection for Dr. Binney was unimpaired by the severance. By the end of September Maurice had become a visitor, and introduced Daniel to his family, while in the spring of 1843 Archdeacon Hare had expressed a desire to assist him in establishing himself elsewhere, should a better opening occur. The opening offered in the summer, and a loan of ^500 from the Archdeacon enabled Daniel to complete the purchase of the business of Mr. Richard Newby at 17 Trinity Street, Cambridge. For a few months the Aldersgate Street shop was kept on under Alexander Macmillan's management, while Daniel took charge of the new venture. But a serious attack of haemorrhage of the lungs, brought on by his exertions in organizing the business, rearranging the stock, etc., obliged him to summon his brother from London. Alexander, himself suffering from rheumatism, came down posthaste by stage-coach in a sharp frost outside, no inside seat being procurable, with the result that both brothers were dis- abled for the moment. It was now evident that Daniel could no longer conduct the Cambridge business single- handed, and, with Archdeacon Hare's strong approval, he and his brother resolved to dispose of the shop in Aldersgate Street and concentrate their business at Cambridge. They did so with regret, not from pecuniary motives, because the London business had so far given no promise of being able to support them both, but because of the opportunities which a residence in London afforded them of " meeting with and hearing from young men — young Scotch ministers, young Dis- senting missionaries, and young men about to leave England for our colonies — who were every now and then calling on us when we were in London." Of these acquaintances undoubtedly the most remarkable was
25
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1844
David Livingstone, whom Daniel and Alexander Macmillan got to know while the explorer was studying medicine and science in London in 1838-1840. The Aldersgate Street shop must also be associated with the earliest essay of the Macmillans in publishing. The first book to bear their name was The Philosophy of Training, a short educational treatise by A. R. Craig, a Glasgow schoolmaster ; while the second, The Three Questions? by William H. Miller, has on the title page of its second edition "Published by D. & A. Macmillan, 57 Aldersgate Street and 17 Trinity Street, Cambridge." By Easter the London house was closed, and the brothers fully committed to the Cambridge venture. The busi- ness prospered in a modest way from the start, owing much to the patronage and support of Archdeacon Hare and his friends, but still more to the ability and person- ality of the senior partner. But Alexander Macmillan, though contentedly and cheerfully accepting a sub- ordinate position in these early years, from the very outset proved that he was an intelligent as well as a trustworthy colleague. Thus he took an active part in the preparation of a catalogue of their stock, a pamphlet of 1 20 pages, which appeared early in 1 844, contributing literary notes under the initials " A. R." The asperity of their criticisms drew a temperate rebuke from Arch- deacon Hare, who resented Daniel's disparagement of Emerson, but cordially applauded the notion of a select catalogue with brief remarks taken from the writings of good judges.
1 The full title was : " The Three Questions : What am I ? Whence came I ? Whither do I go ? " It was " subscribed " by Alexander Macmillan, and a good story is told that when Mr. Longman saw it he answered the questions thus : " A Scot ; from
the Land of Cakes ; to the d 1 ! " See Article in The Bookman,
May, 1901, p. 38.
26
1846] MOVE TO TRINITY STREET
The brothers remained at 17 Trinity Street until 1 846, when they moved to I Trinity Street on acquiring the business of Mr. Thomas Stevenson, who had died in the previous year. Stevenson had succeeded John Nicholson — the second son of John Nicholson, known as "Maps," whose portrait by Reinagle hangs in the University Library — in 1822, when the business was already established for 70 years, and died in 1845. No. i Trinity Street, to which the younger Nicholson moved in 1807, *s a corner house, admirably central, and with delightful views from the upper windows. The struc- ture has undergone extensive alterations at different times, and is now entirely given over to business pur- poses, but a great many of the old rooms remain, and most of them have interesting associations. The drawing-room, which faces west towards the Senate House, with King's Chapel on the left, was the west end of the present big room on the first floor, the other half being the business room in which Daniel Macmillan made his headquarters. It was also a sort of informal common-room frequented after four o'clock Hall by undergraduates and dons, who came to chat and read the newspapers, a pleasant custom revived of late years by Mr. Robert Bowes, the present head of the Cambridge business. Daniel's bedroom faced south, looking on St. Mary's, and the old dining-room on the second floor has a portrait of Thackeray to commemorate his visit in November, 1851, for the delivery of his Lectures on the English Humourists, when he lunched there. The little room, now devoted to Mathematics, facing north, was where Kingsley in 1850 showed the brothers the MS. of Alton Locke, which, however, they did not then publish.1
1Kingsley's earlier books were mostly published by Parker, but Macmillans published Alexandria and her Schools and Phaethon before Westward Ho !
27
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1844
He was already Vicar of Eversley, and appeared, according to the recollection of Mr. Bowes, in a sort of sailor's dress. On the third floor was another little room, which Alexander Macmillan used as a smoking-room after his marriage. This was the scene of a symposium, caricatured by the artist Ludovici— "Ludo" the brothers used to call him — at which a German doctor said to Kingsley, who was smoking a churchwarden pipe, "Vot do you know of philosophy ?" Mr. Robert Bowes, the son of Daniel and Alexander's elder sister, came up from Scotland as a boy of eleven to join his uncles in 1846, and soon afterwards a book- binding department was added to the business, and carried on in rooms at the back of the premises ; but in 1849 it was transferred to other hands and the rooms used for other purposes. In the early years, during which the retail business was Alexander's special province, his desk was at the back of what was then the front shop. On his brother's marriage Alexander stayed on in Trinity Street, while Daniel moved to new quarters in Regent Street. But in 1855, in order to save Daniel from the risk of exposure in bad weather, they changed houses. On Daniel's death in 1857 Alexander returned to Trinity Street, after the house had been rearranged to accom- modate the two families, and lived there until his move to Tooting in 1863.
Of the first few years of partnership at Cambridge there is little record outside the letters in Mr. Hughes' life of Daniel. It was a red letter day for the brothers when in November, 1844, Wordsworth, then the guest of Whewell, the Master of Trinity, came at Archdeacon Hare's request to call on Daniel. Wordsworth paid several visits to the shop "especially one long one, in which he dwelt on the influence Scotland had on him in
28
1 847] DANIEL'S ILL HEALTH
early life, and how he had sought in the Excursion to bring out the spiritual life of Scotland, which he thought had never been adequately sung by any of her poets, who had mainly confined themselves to the humanities." On that occasion Wordsworth wrote his name in at least one of the copies of his works on sale. In 1846, as we have seen, they were joined by their nephew, Robert Bowes, and in 1 847 Daniel was able to say in a letter to Archdeacon Hare ' ' things go very smoothly and prosperously with us, and my brother is a very great comfort and help to ms."
But from the very beginning of their Cambridge partnership right on to his death, Daniel's constant ill- health necessitated long and repeated absences from home. The trips to Hastings in 1844, to Scotland in 1846, and to France in 1847 were of short duration, but from October, 1848, until at least the middle of April, 1 849, he was at Torquay, recruiting after a serious breakdown. In October, 1 853, he was again at Torquay for several months. In July, 1854, he was at Cromer, returning to Torquay in August, and remaining there till the end of October. Six months later he was once more at Torquay, where he remained from April till October, 1855. Thus for months at a time Alexander Macmillan was frequently left in charge of the business when it was at its most critical stage, and it is not too much to say that he interpreted his responsibilities with remarkable fidelity, loyalty and conscientiousness. During these periods of absence the brothers corre- sponded daily — indeed Alexander often wrote twice a day. His report, moreover, was not merely confined to the state of business, sales, orders, etc. ; he made a point of letting his brother know who had been in the shop, the inquiries after his health, and any University gossip that
29
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1848
was likely to interest him. The difficulty of the situa- tion could not be better expressed than in the words of Mr. George Macmillan, when he observes that this arrangement, "while it threw more and more of the burden of the business upon my father, prepared him when the time came to carry on the work alone, but always, as he felt to the last, under the inspiration of his brother's example. . . . All proposals for publica- tion were fully discussed, and no step taken without consultation. This was indeed carrying on business under exceptional difficulties, and the strain upon the partner on the spot, and the anxiety to his brother, who was then struggling against constant ill-health, to keep in touch with and guide his younger brother, must have been tremendous." Add to this that even as late as August, 1855, tne brothers were seriously hampered by their dependence on a succession of partners who, while providing a limited amount of capital, contributed little or nothing in the way of intelligence or flair, and constantly blocked the legitimate enterprise of the brothers. Yet to say, as Mr. Hughes does, that * ' the perfect accord between them was never broken for a day " is substantially true. Daniel's ill-health occasionally inclined him to an excess of caution, and Alexander more than once betrayed some irritation at his brother's habit of incorporating in private letters passages which, if detached from their context, might have saved him the trouble of writing fresh letters to authors or customers. But the only time he was seriously annoyed with his brother was when Daniel, depressed by their financial prospects, spoke of reducing his diet as unnecessarily liberal.
The brothers, as we have seen, lived over the book- shop, and until 1851, when Alexander married, the faith-
3°
1848] THE TRINITY STREET HOUSEHOLD
ful Ellen Stead — "kind and diligent and scoldy" — was in charge of the household. Before their marriage they took in undergraduates as lodgers, some of whom became life-long friends, as in the case of Hoets, a fellow commoner of Trinity Hall ; but they were not always so fortunate. There were always several assistants in the shop, of whom Mr. Fraser, who afterwards accom- panied Alexander Macmillan to London, Mr. T. G. Bain (now of Charles Street, Haymarket), and Mr. Robert Bowes deserve special mention. During these early years, when the brothers were mostly engaged in the retail business, the chief responsibility of that depart- ment fell on Alexander. The hours were very long : 1 ' we closed nominally at 8 o'clock in term time," writes Mr. Bowes, "and were frequently at work till much later." Alexander was early and late at the shop, and often unable to get out till after dark. His recreations were limited to a rare visit to the theatre, an occasional excur- sion on the river, and walks. In the summer of 1855 he says that it struck him that he had hardly an idea what sort of people the general public of Cambridge was when it was at its ease enjoying itself. But he had many pleasant chats with his friends during and after business hours, dined out fairly often with the Brimleys, Dennises, and at other houses, and liked to entertain a few men quietly at home. About the year 1848 he made the acquaintance of Mr. William Amps, a favourite pupil of Walmisley the Professor of Music, and subse- quently organist of King's from 1855 to 1876, who used to come and play his accompaniments while he sang Scotch songs.
"One result of this intercourse," writes Mr. Bowes, "was that he introduced Amps to Tennyson's poems, and that led to the composition of the ' Six Vocal
3*
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1848-
Quartets ' : ' Move eastward happy earth,' ' She sleeps, her breathings are not heard,' ' Now sleeps the crimson petal,' 'Why are we weighed upon with heaviness,' ' Flow down cold rivulet to the sea,' ' Fill the cup and fill the can.' Mr. Amps says that my uncle not only suggested his doing something, but that he actually made the above selection. Later Amps set other of Tennyson's poems to music, among them 'The splen- dour falls on castle walls,' which my uncle used sometimes to sing.
" In the winter of 1 848 my uncle was laid up with his first attack of Sciatica. Mr. Amps says that he frequently called and played to him when he was lying in bed helpless, and suffering great pain."
But, above and beyond all other pursuits, Alexander Macmillan found his chief recreation in reading. His appetite was by no means blunted by the perusal of the works submitted for publication, mostly of a serious nature in these early years, but turned with avidity to the best and most characteristic work of his contemporaries. As early as 1842 he had hailed Tennyson as a classic, and devoured every volume as it came out. He was greatly impressed by Jane Eyrey the heroine of which he describes as " a sort of English Consuelo" and amongst other notable books of the time which he read with delight when they were brand-new, mention may be made of dough's Bothie and Thackeray's Pendennis and The Newcomes. His flair was seldom at fault : he recognised the charm of Paul Heyse fifty-five years ago just as he recognised the genius of derk Maxwell. But his taste for fiction and poetry did not cause him to neglect the claims of more serious literature. He read every word that Maurice wrote with unabated delight, and followed the theological controversies of the time with the closest attention. Lastly, we may note amongst
32
i8ss] UNIVERSITY FRIENDS
the standard works which greatly influenced him at this time, the Journal of George Fox, Plato's Dialogues, and the ballad poetry of Scotland.
From the earliest years of his residence in Cambridge Alexander Macmillan took a keen interest in the work of the University. In his letters to his brother Daniel he never failed to mention the latest awards of University prizes or to tell him who were the favourites for fellow- ships and other distinctions. This, after all, was natural enough since the shop was a rendezvous of dons and studious undergraduates, many of whom were intimate personal friends of the brothers. Amongst these were "the Olympian Thompson" ; W. G. Clark ; the mathe- maticians, Todhunter and Barnard Smith ; and the three great Cambridge scholars, Westcott, Lightfoot and Hort. Hort was already a miracle of industry who alternately amazed and alarmed his friends. Indeed it was said to be his common practice in those days to sit up reading all night until chapel, after which he went to bed, making his breakfast at dinner in Hall at 4 p.m. These Snark- like habits were not compatible with a wide range of acquaintances, but Hort's friendship with the brothers, based on their common love of books, was intimate and life-long. Another brilliant young undergraduate friend was Sebastian ("Bass") Evans, the younger brother of the late Sir John Evans, whose remarkable versatility afterwards found vent in half a dozen channels — poetry, painting, designing,1 journalism, law, politics, and archae- ology— and who in later years was a valued contributor to Macmillan s Magazine. Another intimate Cambridge friend was George Brimley, the librarian of Trinity College, a fine literary critic and reviewer, a constant
1Dr. Sebastian Evans designed the original monogram of the firm.
C 33
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1848
contributor to the Examiner and the Spectator in Rintoul's day, and the author of a remarkable study of Tennyson's poetry. George Brimley was a brilliant if somewhat paradoxical talker, for chronic ill-health often warped his judgment, as well as an accomplished writer, and Alexander Macmillan held him in sincere affection and deeply regretted his premature death. Brimley 's sisters were highly educated girls of fine character, and in Caroline, the eldest, Alexander Macmillan found, a few years later, a wife whose intellectual, no less than her moral qualities, rendered her a true helpmeet.
In the privately printed Reminiscences of an old West Country Clergyman, by the Rev. W. H. Thornton, there is on pp. 71-73 an account of a small Society known as "The Synagogue." Mr. Thornton matricu- lated at Trinity College in October, 1849, an<^ to°^ n*s degree in January, 1853, and his recollections are of this period. The meetings were held in the rooms of the Rev. W. W. Howard, Fellow of Sidney Sussex College, on Sunday nights usually after Hall, Thornton being introduced by his cousin, A. A. Vansittart, who had been bracketed Senior Classic in 1847. Mr. Thornton says that they usually met at Howard's rooms about seven :
The learned men fought over Greek Testament and difference of MSS. Afterwards we had supper, drank some audit ale, and finished with reading by one of the party of some difficult sermon, generally by Archer Butler, and free discussion thereon. All the time we smoked and went back to our rooms by midnight. It was a great privilege for me to be allowed to be present, and the discussions, though free, were always conducted by men who were believers.
34
1848] LETTERS TO HIS BROTHER
Mr. Thornton says in a letter that he had seen, but not often, both the Macmillans at the meetings. They were continued for some years afterwards ; in Howard's rooms till he left Cambridge to take up his duties as an Inspector of Schools and afterwards in those of Van- sittart. Alexander Macmillan spoke of it as "the Church in the Family," and of those attending as Howard, Vansittart, George Brimley, and W. G. Clark.
Outside Cambridge Alexander Macmillan's closest friends were the Wilsons, James MacLehose, and Mr. Nutt,1 with whom he often stayed on his way through London, and who often spent a week-end with him in Cambridge.
In the autumn of 1848 Daniel Macmillan was ordered away for his health, and spent several months at Torquay. The nature of the correspondence that passed between the brothers may be illustrated by the following extracts :
Cambridge, October 15, 1848. To Daniel Macmillan.
I am very glad to find you have got into such good hands as Dr. Tetley's and Mrs. Mayo's, to which lady I beg you will present my most respectful love and tell her that in my brother she has a very valuable but very ticklish charge : that she will require a very firm and resolute hand to keep him in the path of common prudence : that what with his huge love of talking and walking and doing everything upon an extravagant scale — except taking care of himself — he is no easy task to manage.
1 Writing on May 5, 1855, he says: "He [Nutt] is altogether as unselfish a man as I ever met with, hardly even excepting Mr. Maurice or my brother Daniel."
35
ALEXANDER MACM1LLAN [1848
October 17, 1848. To the same.
I was very glad to have your report of what Mr. Maurice said. I find everything he says as a new spring of life to me. . . . Do you know George Fox puts me marvellously in mind of Socrates. Of course there is a wide difference, but still there is in that drawing of men's attention to what was in themselves — in Socratic language — looking to the soul how it might become perfect — in Quaker language going to Christ their inward Teacher — that causes a wonderful similarity.
The following remarks were prompted by a letter from George Wilson :
October 22, 1848. To the same.
What a noble and tender soul speaks there : surely it is the voice of heart which has been attuned to harmony with the centre of all harmony. I did not know him before he was afflicted. I suppose he was always beautiful in spirit, but his letters, and indeed all his utterances, seem to me to have the tone of a man who has been refined by fire. ' Whom the Lord loveth He chasteneth."
October 24, 1848. To the same.
I'll suggest that when you want me to answer any questions you make an abstract of them on a piece of paper separate from your letter — which I require to be filled with pleasant gossip, advice, moral reflection, and general discussion on men and things you see and think of. If mine are dry it arises mainly from the natural barrenness of my brain, bald utterance and general confusedness of outward and inward man, but partly also that during the day, as you may guess, I am rather busy and at night a little tired — or rather lazy,
36
1848] VISIT FROM GUIZOT
fancying that I am tired — and then I do love my pipe in my mouth, my feet on the hobs and a book in my hand immensely. ... I am in excellent health, excel- lent spirits, excellent temper, in every way well — except I do feel a little anxious to hear the tone of your mind a little cheerfuller.
October 26, 1848. To the same.
You really must keep up your spirits. Think what a fine thing it will be when you and I in prime health can be together relieving and assisting one another. Keep your future usefulness before your eye and mind your health. You have done more for the business than I shall ever do in a hundred years. It would be absurd if I were to grudge you rest, when you want it, and it is absurd in you to grudge yourself. You are working when you are taking care of health.
On October 27 Alexander notes a visit from Arch- deacon Hare * ' with his noble kindly face and greeting," and in the letter bearing date November 2 he gives an interesting account of a visit from Whewell, Guizot, and the Belgian Ambassador :
Whewell bought a book by Thiers, and the Belgian purchased and carried off with him some books of Facetiae. ... I had a good look at Guizot. He is a little man with an oval, whitely [sic] face and very beautiful black — or dark rather — open eyes, with those round energetic lids which I have noticed in remarkable men which seem to grasp what they look at.
During this winter Alexander Macmillan suffered a great deal from sciatica, and submitted himself patiently to the drastic remedies then in vogue. On November 1 7th he describes his experiences when chloroform was administered to him: "It is a most peculiar stuff — a
37
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1849
kind of ethereal tipsiness," and for some time he was unable to sleep without recourse to morphia. At Christmas he spent a fortnight with his brother at Torquay, and the letters are not resumed till January. The goodness of Dr. Tetley " quite dumbfounded" Alexander Macmillan, and on his return he exclaims, " He really is a noble fellow."
Daniel's absence was a constant subject of inquiry in the shop. "I cannot stop to tell all who ask for you," but he specially mentions Holden (the editor of Aristophanes), Matheson, George Brimley,and Fitzjames Stephen. Hoets, their lodger and friend, had suggested their starting a business at the Cape, his own native place, and Alexander discusses the notion on January 3ist, 1849 : " With our health we could expect nowhere to spend our lives either more profitably to ourselves and others or more pleasantly. But this lack of health and power to fulfil one's calling is a serious drawback." He hopes for good results for both of them when the summer comes, but evidently thought seriously of Hoets' suggestion. This letter concludes in a more cheerful vein : " Here is the new Pendennis, so you must excuse my cutting you for the night." At the end of February we find him reading Yeast again with redoubled interest, and Froude's Nemesis of Faith, which caused him unmitigated pain. Writing on February 28th he has some interesting remarks apropos of a conversation with an undergraduate whom he had misjudged :
This humanity that we have is in no single, simplest or most shallow instance to be named \_sic\ suddenly. There is an Inner Man whom we cannot see under even the vilest or shallowest face. When we learn to reverence the God within, then comes charity to our hearts — rather is charity not this very thing ?
38
1849] KINGSLEY AND FROUDE
March 5, 1849.
I am very glad to hear so good an account of — . I am afraid that his selfish theory has a great truth lying in it which the anti-selfish theory overlooks, and therefore fails to convince. It is like the ' ' private judgment" and "upon trust" controversy, men poking each other's eyes out about which oar pulls the boat. After all it is very clear that if I do a right and proper, or a kind and generous action — and if it is an act of my own — a conscious act — I do it for a reason. That reason doubtless is with all rational minds because \\. fulfils my proper being — in other words, satisfies us. It may be contrary to our apparent interest — certainly it is con- ducive to our central harmony. When Christ said " he that will find his life must lose it," it seems to me to be taken for granted that the finding of life must be desirable — only men are continually seeking after a narrow, exclusive life, not seeing that our life is bound up by infinite cords to all other men — as brothers, citizens, members of a Church. I cannot be myself till I go out of myself and find my true self in others.
March 6, 1849.
I wish I could send you the volume of Fraser containing Kingsley's Yeast. Hoskin lent it to me from the Union. It is really magnificent, somewhat frag- mentary and crude in its outward appearance, but informed by a most coherent and purposeful spirit. The sudden winding up is painful. I confess I cannot see what good purpose Mr. Froude could possibly have in writing that book of his. What he says about the inconsistencies of Christians in their treatment of the poor, and also in other respects, is very instructive to Christians. But that chaotic, uncertain character — " all things are out of joint " — surely it too is instructive to those who have firm ground — teaching them to sympa- thise with those who have not yet reached the desired haven — but to the poor strugglers, so numerous in our
39
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1849
time, it is not well to have the confusion worse con- founded, the chaos made more chaotic.
Any adverse criticism of Maurice and Hare stirred the Macmillans greatly, and an article in the English Review roused Alexander's indignation. Writing on the yth of March, 1849, he speaks of it as a declaration of war which "had better be met by sword-thrusts and gunshot wounds — not by ruffled temper." But the following extract shows that he was not always in favour of militant methods :
March 9.
I have been reading the Gorgias of Plato. It is exceedingly fine. It would be quite worth a philan- thropic man's while to print these Dialogues as cheap tracts to circulate among the more intelligent of the working men in our large towns. Any Society for diffusing useful knowledge could not do better than diffuse them. One ought to learn from Socrates that violence does not form any essential part of the means of propagating it.
Only a few days later he was much amused by hearing a University sermon in which the preacher spoke of the "poor blind pagans." "However," he adds, "Mr.
is an excellent worthy man, and one always
learns something from him — if it were only negatively." But he has no patience with the Scotch landlord of his brother-in-law who let his cottars rot in damp dens while he complacently announced that he was waiting for the millennium! On March 1 3th he writes : " Jenny Lind was here last night. I should have been glad to have heard her, but £i is. stumped me," and in the following letter we have at second hand an interesting picture of Dr. Prince Lee, the first Bishop of Manchester :
40
1 849] PRINCE LEE
March 15.
Hoets l came in upon us unexpectedly last night just as I was going to bed. He has succeeded to his mind. The bishop is willing to ordain him, and has procured for him a curacy in Salford, where he will be in the thick of human life with all its struggles. The bishop made him and his friend, Mr. Ebden — who is an old friend of Dr. Lee's — stop at his house and kept up talking till about one in the morning. Hoets is delighted with the worthy bishop, whom he describes as a jolly little fellow with none of your narrow, bigoted illiberality. He offered to ordain him at Easter, but Hoets begged off, as he did not feel quite up to the examination. I was quite delighted with one thing the bishop said to him : " Don't go and cram up Pearson on the Creed, Wheatley on the Common Prayer, nor your Church history so as to come and tell me who the Gnostics and Marcionites and other ancient sects were. I want you to learn, if you can, who the Wesleyan Methodists and Independents and Socialists and other sects living now are, so that you may be able to deal with them when you meet with them in your daily duties." He is a very excellent, worthy little man, but nobody is perfect. He says he cannot make Maurice out, and thinks Hare a much greater man. He was saying to Bunsen he felt quite ashamed of being a bishop while Hare was not. Bunsen answered : ' ' Hare is a prophet, you are a priest." He told this to Hoets with great glee.
The subject of marriage had already begun to occupy his thoughts, but he disclaims all definite intentions :
1 John William van Rees Hoets was born at the Cape, where he inherited property at Rondebosch, but came to Europe when he was about sixteen years of age, and after spending some years on the continent entered Trinity Hall, and graduated as I5th senior optime in 1 846. Ordained in 1 849, he went back to the Cape, but after several years he returned to England, where he engaged in business as a shipbroker. Alexander Macmillan wrote of him in 1864 as "an exceedingly handsome man, generous and noble as any Englishman could be." Mr. Hoets died only a couple of years ago.
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1849
March 22.
Indeed, my dear fellow, I don't see how any marrying is to be brought about. I'll tell you what : I cannot set my heart on any one till I have had some opportunity of intercourse, and how that is to be brought about I know not, and taking a rush at a fancied good I don't think wholesome or safe, so I think I must e'en die a bachelor.
He is reading Plato's Theaetetus^ but for the moment has set it aside for John Sterling's novel Arthur Coningsby (published anonymously in 1833), which he found interesting, though most imperfect as a work of art, and a few days later some light is thrown on his prospects by the mention of an invitation to spend the evening with the Brimleys : " tea and music and ladies' society instead of long clays and grog. A good ex- change?" Hort's "vehement intellectual energy" is pleasantly illustrated in the following letter :
April 10.
I had a long chat with our friend Fenton Hort last night. He wants to know all about Mr. Maurice — what he thinks on this, that and the other thing— among others, this vexed, foolish question about marry- ing a deceased wife's sister. Wide sympathies has our friend Fenton. He is quite sure of a scholarship this term. Do you know he stood very high in the Craven examination next to Williams (J. D.) and equal, if not better, than Beamont. They say that if he had read classics exclusively he would have come out first. He must be a precious clever fellow. His natural history, politics, polemics — and all the other * ies ' and ' ics ' — what does he not know? And then the last important novel, Jane Eyre or dough's Bothie — or anything notable — Fenton notes it. Truly a Catholic nature. He is terribly set upon having Mr. Kingsley to preach
42
1 850] "IN MEMORIAM"
before the University here. Could Mr. Maurice do anything towards it ?
The brothers were reunited in the summer of 1849, and there is a gap in their correspondence until the autumn of 1850, when Daniel went off to the Lakes and Scotland for his wedding tour. Kingsley's visit to Cambridge in the summer of that year prompted the following letter to Hort :
Cambridge, July 4, 1850. To Fenton Hort.
We have been enjoying a very great treat in Kingsley's visit, as you may guess when I tell you that even his finest writings are not up to the rich vigour and freshness of his conversation — especially when com- bined with the hearty, manly look of the man. We have had all things over with him, old and new, sacred and profane, divine and human. Among other things, the In Memoriam. . . . We are all agreed that it places Tennyson more emphatically and securely among the immortals than any of his previous writings. I can, however, conceive your dislike both to the " must needs have universalism to sustain love," as you phrase it, and also to "Thou madest death" : and in part sympathise with it — that is if the two statements were viewed separately. But it seems to me that if you view them in relation to the fact that " God is Love," and that man is made in God's image, i.e. is an independent will, or as Tennyson has so wonderfully expressed it in that same poem,
" Our wills are ours we know not how, Our wills are ours to make them thine."
I say when one sees these two views in the light of these latter considerations, they are the only possible ones. You really must read the whole over again half-a-dozen times and never mind "Theology" ; you may depend on it there will come to you wonderful meanings from it. ... That marriage poem at the end refers to the then
43
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1850
approaching (now fulfilled) marriage of his sister to Lushington of Glasgow, who was an intimate of both Tennyson and Hallam. By the bye, have you heard of his own marriage to a Miss Selwood? . . . All his friends are delighted. Kingsley is in ecstasies. . . . Maurice is gone to Switzerland. I have not heard whether he completed his ' ' Philosophy " article before he went. I shall try to learn. Furnivall was down taking his master's [degree] and stopped with us.
Furnivall is of course the late Dr. Furnivall, who was one of the group of social reformers who founded the Christian Socialist movement nearly sixty years ago and of whom Mr. J. M. Ludlow is now the sole survivor. Alexander Macmillan's devotion to Maurice and Kingsley, both leaders of the movement, made him a willing recruit, and Mr. Bowes confirms the impression derived from Mr. Ludlow's correspondence that he contributed to the journal the Christian Socialist (the successor of Politics for the People), the first number of which was issued on November 2, 1850. The number for June 7, 1851, contains a communication on The Existence of Evil, and the Existence of Good signed " Amos Yates," a pseudonym which he adopted in his paper on Tennyson's Maud in the first volume of Macmillans Magazine.
In the middle of July Alexander Macmillan took a short holiday in the North, visiting the Wilsons in Edinburgh and staying with his married sister Janet Wilson at Stewarton. But by the beginning of August he was back at Cambridge, and embodied some of his experiences in the following interesting letter to Fenton Hort:
Cambridge, August 8, 1850. About converting you to Socialism I am not solicitous. Believing in my deepest soul that the central
44
1 850] GEORGE WILSON
principle is right, I am yet by no means cocksure about many details which I yet accept. And in these circum- stances I am rather glad than not to have a few hearty opponents who will simply look at the thing and find as many faults as they can, and as that seems a not uncongenial line for you, by all means maintain your opponent — unconverted — position and hit as hard as ever you can wherever you honestly see a feeble place. You will teach us where our weak points lie. The first volume of Maurice's History was published about a fortnight since. Daniel has been reading it in the intervals permitted from the more serious business he has in hand — even courtship. I don't know if you have heard he is going to be tied for life in about three weeks. ... I am sorry you had not the opportunity of meeting our dear friend George Wilson. He would quite have fulfilled all your expectations about him. I never spend a day or two with him without coming away humbled and edified. A life spent in almost incessant pain, sleepless nights and restless days, and yet such serenity and cheerfulness and lovingness. And to think of the actual labour the man goes through. Nine lectures a week, review articles, papers for Societies, correspondence, a Life of Cavendish, a popular treatise on Chemistry for the Chambers he has been at work on lately too. Truly it is a beautiful and efficient Soul that works in that frail, shattered shell of a body of his. We had a long chat together about Universal- ism and its cognates. He told me a capital story of an old Scotch minister who was being badgered by some smart young free-thinker, who put as a poser to him, "And do you really think that Plato and Socrates and all the noble and good men of Heathendom will be excluded from Heaven ?" " Ah," says the old man, "if I meet them there I'll be delighted to see them, and if not I am quite sure there will be a good reason why." This seemed to me very beautiful. Don't you think it so ?
My objection to the habit of bandying charges of
45
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1850
heresy is : That it really appears somewhat presumptuous in any man to suppose that his view of infinite truth is all-inclusive, and that nothing that seems to him to contradict his own notions can be true. What I should like to see would be this. Let all honest thinkers think honestly, and if honestly they are impelled by the spirit to speak, for Heaven's sake let them. If an Athanasius or any other man has seen something which seems to him infinitely true, let him hold by it if all the world say Nay. But why he should call it the Catholic truth without which men must perish everlastingly I cer- tainly don't see. That what I see is true to me, and indeed absolutely true to me, it is needful for me to hold — that it is exclusively the truth, and that I am to curse other men for not holding it, seems to me simply wicked. For the very same reason that I may not hold my own beliefs feebly or in a half-spirit, but should stick by them as my very life, for the very same reason may I not dare to intrude upon another man's faiths — if they are indeed his honest and sincere beliefs you may depend upon it they are true — and it must be in justi- fying their truth that you show them their error. This outcry about heresy is a hateful and evil thing — born of the Devil, the father of Lies, for the very purpose of rooting out all faith from men's souls. . . . The Church which is knit together in love, which is the body of Him who is the Fulness of Him who is Love, I know and believe in and I know that it has all truth : the Church which is Dr. Pusey, or Mr. Newman, or Athanasius, the church of Dogma and Superstition, I do not believe in, I am utterly sick of it, and hope our beloved Church of England will rid herself of it alto- gether. ... I would only say in reference to the passage in Tennyson which offended your orthodoxy [that] he might have used the phrase in the same sense as the Bible writer who asked, " Is there evil in the city and God hath not done it ?" or indeed a thousand places where he is represented as sending pain and afflicting men : and besides that, death in Tennyson's mind was
46
1850] VIEWS ON SOCIALISM
not lookt upon, perhaps, as otherwise than an affliction for good. And indeed I confess I cannot see any other view of the case without having two authors of the Universe. However, upon the whole I think I had better not enter into this discussion, simply protesting against the right of you eminent theologians to shy orthodox stones — very hard ones — from the lofty pin- nacle where either special favour of Heaven or your own conceit (judge ye which) has placed you upon the heads of poor unfortunates walking in the valley of the shadow of death, or doubt or difficulty — only for the fearful crime of speaking what one honestly thinks. . . .
Alexander Macmillan's literary ambitions were at an early age restricted to the sphere of suggestion, but his association with Maurice, Hughes, Kingsley and Ludlow in the Christian Socialist movement lends interest to an unpublished tract, " British Industry and Socialism," cast in the form of a dialogue between tc Mr. Bull, a city merchant/* and " Amos Yates, a small dealer from the country " — one of the very few attempts at sustained composition left amongst his papers. There is no date in the notebook containing the dialogue, which has some annotations in pencil in another hand — I think Mr. Ludlow' s — but a reference to Mary Barton (published in October, 1848) and to the * ' June Insurrection " as recent events seem to point to the year 1849 or 1%S°* Amos Yates, the small dealer, clearly represents Alexander Macmillan's point of view, and, as we have seen, he used the name on other occasions as a literary pseudonym. Mr. Bull expresses regret for the existence of so much misery and poverty, but deprecates resort to rash measures. The evils are the inevitable outcome of competition. Amos Yates, on the other hand, by the use of the
47
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1850
to young men on More's Utopia and Plato's Republic — incomplete, but giving, so far as it goes, a detailed account of the latter, of which he speaks with the greatest enthusiasm as "one of the most wonderful utterances that has ever proceeded from the mind and pen of man beyond the influence of direct Christian Revelation." He makes a good point in insisting that though apparently much more practical in its outward form, More's Utopia is really far less capable of realisa- tion, whereas " Plato's ideal Republic is to a great extent capable of being realised by us here in England, and much of the true blessedness which he promises us can be obtained without straying beyond the bounds of our own towns or away from the circle of our own duties or our own family life." He notes the remarkable coincidence between the language used by ' ' this wonder- ful old heathen" and the discourse of our Lord about the true shepherd and the hireling, as well as other strange anticipations.
Daniel Macmillan, who had become engaged in June, 1850, to Frances, daughter of Mr. Orridge of Cam- bridge, was married on the 4th of September, and spent his wedding trip in the English Lakes and in Scotland. During his absence Alexander kept him fully advised of all that went on in Cambridge, forwarding friendly messages and keeping him acquainted with the latest University gossip. Daniel was sincerely anxious that his brother should follow his own excellent example, and Alexander was not uninfluenced by these friendly hints. " I am really quite a partner of your happiness. It seems so full and shining that moon of yours that it almost warms me at this distance."
But while he shared Daniel's admiration for the young lady specially designated as his help-meet — whom
5°
1851] MARRIAGE
he did ultimately marry — Alexander was by no means sanguine as to the result of his suit :
I have the completest sympathy in the high estimate you give of C. B.'s character — but I must confess I have not the same confidence in my own power of answering to its excellencies. My habits and in some degree my natural constitution ... so totally vary from all that is required in married life that I never think of myself as a married man without something like trembling and fear.
However he did not despair of becoming ultimately a "tame animal." Daniel Macmillan, warned by a recurrence of his lung trouble, spent the last fortnight of his wedding tour at Torquay, but returned to Cam- bridge about the middle of October, and the brothers were not separated until the following summer.
In spite of Alexander Macmillan's misgivings, the attachment between him and Caroline Brimley ripened steadily in the early months of 1851, and after a short engagement they were married in August of that year. Writing on August 4 to Fenton Hort, Alexander Macmillan mentions that he had asked Kingsley to come and marry him, but that Kingsley had started for Germany before his letter reached Chelsea. " I had such a beautiful note from his wife, and another (written from Baden) from Kingsley himself." The rest of the letter is mainly devoted to a discussion of the Guardian and its disingenuous tone towards Kingsley and Maurice, but includes a reference to a talk with Arthur Stanley about the Oxford Commission and Dr. Arnold. On the eve of his marriage a few days later, he returns to the Guardian, but in a more friendly mood :
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1851
Cambridge, August 9, 1851. To Fenton Hort.
... I very much agree with your apology for the Guardian — so far as it goes. There was a capital anti-Popery article in this last week's number, which has considerably mollified my feelings towards [it]. ... I can not but hate anything calling itself authority which seeks to suppress that upon which alone a true manhood can rest — human responsibility, human freedom — the blessed burden God has laid on us, which we dare not ask any one calling himself pope or priest to bear for us. ... I am going to be ' ' turned off " on Wednes- day. I have taken lodgings for a week at Ambleside. I may stop longer, but I may be inclined to go to Kendal and then to Scotland. . . .
A week later he wrote from Ambleside to George Brimley to say that "married life hitherto has my heartiest approval," adding, in a more serious vein, how deeply sensible he was of Brimley 's fraternal attention and kindness on the wedding day.
At the close of the year Alexander, like his brother, was deeply moved by the campaign conducted against Maurice on the ground that his views on Christian Socialism were incompatible with his tenure of his Professorship at King's College :
Cambridge, January 15, 1851. To Fenton Hort.
I was in town the other day and had a complete account of the matter between Maurice and the Council of King's College. The affair originated with Sir Harry Inglis and some of the Low Church lay members of the Council. The clerical portion to a man stood up for him. It was finally settled that a sub-committee of enquiry should be appointed to determine the question of Mr. Maurice's orthodoxy. The enquiry seems to
5*
1851] CHRISTIAN SOCIALISM
have been made in the shape of visits to the tailors,1 which gave very considerable satisfaction to the visitors. I forgot to tell you that the enquiring committee were all clerical. The Bishop of London, the Bishop of Lich- field, Mr. Anderson, chaplain of Lincoln's Inn, Dr. Jelf, and someone else whose name I forget. . . . Well, the report was to this effect : That the Council had a grateful sense of Mr. Maurice's energetic and valuable services, and felt the strongest confidence in the soundness of his principles. That the Christian Socialism which Mr. Maurice was connected with, although they thought the name injudicious, was intended by its promoters, includ- ing Mr. Maurice, as the best counteractive to the thing commonly called Socialism, and that they did not think any blame could be attached to the efforts that were being made beyond this injudiciousness. At the same time they could not help regretting that Mr. Maurice's name had been connected with publications and people of questionable character and orthodoxy. At the same time, making allowance for certain obscurities of style, there was nothing in Mr. Maurice's own writings as contained in these publications or elsewhere that could in any measure justify diminished confidence in his soundness of principle, etc., etc. The prophet upon receipt of this report (which was carried by a large majority on the Council, the opposition being as before confined to the Low Church lay party) sent them a char- acteristic reply. Thanking them for their expressed confidence, he said that he could not allow himself for a moment to regret the conduct he had pursued in regard to Christian Socialism, and that he would still continue to do what seemed to him right in the matter. This, I think, is the whole of what I learned from Ludlow.2 The prophet himself was at Exmouth, and I did not see him of course. . . .
1 i.e. the Tailors' Associations formed by the Christian Socialists.
'^/2 Ludlow's account agrees substantially with that given in JelPs letter and Maurice's reply in which he defines Christian Socialism. (See Life of F. D. {Maurice, by his son, vol. ii. pp. 90-2.)
53
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1853
Alexander Macmillan's eldest child, born on December 20, 1852, bore the names Malcolm Kingsley, Kingsley standing godfather. In announcing the event to Hort, Alexander Macmillan alludes to a curious episode in the annals of club life :
Cambridge, December 24, 1852. I confess a strong rejoicing at the prospect of a non-party Ministry, and heartily pray that it may succeed. Have you seen the exhibition of " Conservative" feeling at the Carlton ? I hope Gladstone will insist either on having these members expelled or on leaving it himself.
The renewed attack on Maurice in connexion with his views on eternal punishment, which led to his resigning his Professorship at King's College, was not without its bearing on Maurice's publishers, as may be gathered from the following letter :
To Daniel Macmillan. Cambridge> S^ l8> l8«-
I went and called on Clayton1 last night to ask if his interdict applied to all Maurice's books, for the lecturers recommended his Moral Philosophy for the Moral Science Tripos. He seemed at a loss, but thought there was no likelihood of his theology being put into such a book. I told him that Maurice could not write on the moral history of man without continual reference to God, whom he thought the moral Governor of the Universe. He then thought it would be safer to com- prehend all his books. I was going with this answer, when he said it gave him great pain to do what he had done, and this led to some talk. I told him I had read the book through when it was passing through the press and since very carefully, and had felt thankful to God for having raised up a man in our time who seemed so able to stem the tide of infidelity that I felt coming on us, and was utterly staggered to find men who I had
1 Rev. Charles Clayton, Fellow and Tutor of Gonville and Caius College.
54
1 853] ADMIRATION FOR MAURICE
every reason to believe had the cause of Christianity at heart denouncing a man who was so nobly vindicating the simple Gospel of Christ's redemption against all gainsayers.
To this Clayton retorted that Alexander Macmillan might be right, but that he felt it his duty to seek to prevent a book which had been misunderstood by so many good men from coming into the hands of immature- minded students :
Of course I could say nothing to this. I only told him I wished him to know that we, in publishing the book and in continuing to help its circulation, were acting conscientiously and, as we believed, helping to vindicate the simplicity of the Gospel from the un- hallowed speculations of men of all kinds.
Six weeks later Daniel Macmillan wrote to his brother to say that he had just seen Maurice, who had been dismissed, adding ' ' He is a grand man, and must endure like other prophets. The good people of the next age will build his tomb." Daniel Macmillan was once more wintering at Torquay, whence he wrote to his brother on October 25 :
Your long and interesting letter to-day was quite a reproof to me. . . . But I hardly ever read — indeed I may say I never read one of your letters with more pleasure. Every line of it showed such staid wisdom— and still more delightful to us than that, such quite solid joy, that it seems to harmonise with the lovely scenery and weather we have here, and to proceed from the same never-changing source of all beauty and goodness and truth, and to speak of a quiet, peaceful, happy Christian home. I was saying to Fanny last night I loved Malcolm for his name's sake, for his father's sake and for his own sake, and because he is our godson, and so the news of his good health was very precious to us.
55
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1853
The publications of the firm had already gone far to justify Daniel Macmillan's statement that, while the retail trade might be a useful auxiliary, his great hopes were in the publishing line. The list for 1852 included Davies and Vaughan's translation of Plato's Republic^ Kingsley's Phaethon, Maurice's Prophets and Kings, Archer Butler's sermons, and Todhunter's Differential Calculus. The bulk of their publications were still theological or educational works, and amongst the latter the works of Todhunter and (in a year or two) of Barnard Smith had begun to achieve a wide circula- tion. In those days, however, publishers did not wait for authors to submit proposals ; they very often met them half way, and the personal relations which Daniel and his brother had established with the ablest young men of the University now began to stand them in good stead. But although the publishing business was grow- ing, the brothers were still sorely hampered by their reliance on their partners. The stocktaking in July, 1853, yielded disappointing results, and from this onward they were increasingly anxious to free themselves from an irksome dependence. These partners had to be constantly consulted, and were frequently obstructive. Thus, speaking of a proposal of Mayor's about Homer in October, 1853, Daniel writes to his brother: " — [the predominant partner of the moment] is our master and holds the money bags," and the insecurity of their position, coupled with his own precarious health, was a frequent source of anxiety and dissatisfaction. At the same time Daniel Macmillan never failed to express his gratitude to and reliance on his brother : " I am sure I shall do all in my power to live as long as I can near such a wife and such a brother." In a letter dated October n, 1853, he apologises for staying away so long, adding
56
1854] "WESTWARD HO!"
"but I have come to the conclusion that whether I die or recover, it would be wisest for me to take it easy." In January, 1854, Alexander Macmillan was up in London stopping with Nutt, and saw a good deal of Maurice ; indeed he seldom writes to his brother without some mention of "the prophet." "Anything about Mr. Maurice is always interesting," and on this occasion he had a long talk with his hero about the Christian Socialist tracts and Kingsley's scheme of carrying war into the enemy's country by making a countercharge of heresy against the "pseudo-orthodox." Alexander Macmillan loved Kingsley, but did not always confide in his judg- ment : " I wish he would not be quite so breathless in his conclusions."
Daniel's children remained in Cambridge while their father was at Torquay, and Alexander seldom wrote without reporting on their progress, appearance, or accomplishments. He regarded them and that ' * excel- lent wise woman," their mother, with an affection which made it the most natural thing in the world for him to make his home theirs after his brother's death.
Colenso and Barnard Smith were the authors most often referred to in the early months of 1854, but West- cott's History of the New Testament Canon was passing through the press, and frequently elicits Alexander's praise ; while among other publications of the year were Maurice's Ecclesiastical History and Sermons on Sacrifice, and Kingsley's Alexandria and her Schools. In a sense 1854 was Kingsley's year, for in June he sent Daniel Macmillan the first sketch of Westward Ho ! and on July 3<Dth Alexander records his impressions after reading the rough draft: "I have been reading Kingsley's novel, and like it immensely. It is very unfinished, having large gaps with only pencilled
57
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1854
hints of what he is going to do, but it certainly has noble passages, and will, I fancy, be a noble whole." Writing the next day, he adds : ' ' I have nearly finished all that Kingsley has sent of the novel. It is the right article, and no mistake." Westward Ho ! which was not published until the following year, was the first strikingly successful and popular venture into the domain of belles lettres made by the Macmillans, and its issue must always be regarded as a notable land- mark in the history of the firm.
Daniel Macmillan, who had gone to Cromer for change in the summer, was disabled by a fresh attack of haemorrhage of the lungs, and at the end of July wrote sadly to his brother that he realised he would " never be well or strong any more." But he gratefully acknow- ledges his brother's " kind, full letters," which he "read over and over," and rallying slowly, was able to move back to his old quarters at Torquay towards the end of August, leaving his brother in charge at Cambridge till November. At the end of August Alexander Macmillan decided to avail himself of the slack season and take a short holiday trip to Scotland with his brother-in-law, George Brimley, but his departure was delayed for a week or more by Brimley's illness. In the interval he spent a week-end at Brighton with his wife and child, of whom he says that " his delight is to discover what you don't want him to do and then do it." Just before starting on September 5th he writes to his brother : 11 Surely God was gracious both to you and me in this strange land, where, without having to kill any Canaan- ites, we have got a promised land." On their arrival in Edinburgh George Brimley was taken dangerously ill, and had to undergo a serious operation, but the skill of Dr. Syme gave him immediate relief, and his
58
1854] VISIT TO EDINBURGH
progress was so rapid that Alexander Macmillan thoroughly enjoyed the last week of his stay. He saw much of Mrs. Wilson, " just as wise and good as ever," but George Wilson was laid up with a broken arm at Rothesay, "the dear noble afflicted man." Writing on September I9th, after a visit to Mrs. Wilson, he says: "You are evidently very dear to her, and your troubles and successes have her hearty sympathy." Mrs. Wilson gave him inter alia an interesting account of George Wilson's investigations into colour blindness, subsequently embodied in a monograph. He had had " quite volumes of letters from all sorts of people, from tailors who matched red and green — thinking them the same colour — to countesses who would put on a scarlet shawl thinking it a nice quiet colour."
Before leaving Edinburgh he dined with Syme, and on his return to Cambridge gave his brother a full account of the entertainment :
Sept. 24, 1854. To Daniel Macmillan.
He has a most beautiful house, with exceedingly pretty grounds and a charming look out from the drawing-room on the Braid Hills, with the Pentlands in the distance. . . . Professor Simpson, the intro- ducer of chloroform, was there, two Yankee doctors, and one from Carlisle. Mrs. Syme and another lady com- pleted the party. I spent a very pleasant evening, and Dr. Simpson drove me in his carriage. He is really a very pleasant, clever fellow. ... I told you I had seen a good deal of Alexander Smith, who promises to cheer George [Brimley] in his solitude. Dallas, the author of that book on " Poetics," ! and Baynes,2 who wrote a book
1 Eneas Sweetland Dallas (1828-1879).
2 Thomas Spencer Baynes (1822-1887), editor of the Edinburgh Guardian, and afterwards Professor of Logic at St. Andrews.
59
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1854
on Logic and is a favourite of Sir W. Hamilton, were at Smith's rooms one night, and they also promise to see after Brimley. Dobell, too, the author of "Balder" and "The Roman," is a great ally of Smith's, and lives out at Corstorphine with his wife, who is an invalid. I was introduced to him one day on the street, and he expressed a great wish to know George, and said if he liked he would be glad to drive him out to his place one day. . . . George is going on excellently well, and is able to drive out every day. Both Syme and Simpson in speaking of him spoke with the respect and affection he deserves.
On his return journey he paid a visit to his married sister Janet (Mrs. Wilson) at Stewarton, and saw James MacLehose at Glasgow. "He was of course as kind and warm-hearted as ever. . . . His shop filled me with envy." In short, he sums up his Scotch trip as a success in every way. Not less cheerful is the tone of his letter of September 3Oth, a red-letter day for the firm:
Kingsley wrote to me to-day, giving me the title of his book. It is "Westward Ho! being the voyages and adventures of Sir Amyas Leigh of Burrough, Co. Devon, in the reign of Queen Elizabeth of glorious memory." A capital title I think.
On October 2nd he alludes to the victory of the Allies at the Alma, and on October 3rd gives an amusing account of his two-year-old son :
To give you any of Malcolm's speeches would require a new system of phonetics. When he does not want to do anything, he says in a most emphatic manner "Bapom (i.e. Malcolm) don't wish." . . . He makes attempts at any sentence you like, m's becoming b's, and 1 being always thrown overboard. He gets very fat and very wilful, likes sugar very much, and has a marvellous good appetite. He has a great fancy for the
60
1854] HOME INFLUENCES
moon, especially when he and I are in a very friendly mood. He looks up in my face and points out of the window and says, "papa, the moon." I don't suppose he means to assert that I am the moon, but that he wants to make me aware of its existence somewhere out in space.
The letter of October 6th strikes a more intimate and serious note :
Your remembrances of our course of life since we came to England should indeed fill us with gratitude and humility and hope. Wonderfully indeed have we been guided and blessed. . . . What do I not owe you, my noble brother, for your patience with my weakness and faults, and for your help and example all these years. God knows, who is the giver of all good gifts and the root of these blessed family ties, and who made that blessed human heart by which indeed we do live really human lives. I am far from being a good man of busi- ness, brother, husband, father or citizen, and yet I feel a power of entering in the blessedness that belongs to all these that gives me hope for myself in spite of all my failings, for it makes me feel that the Spirit of God of order and love is at least striving with me and trying to help me in spite of my worthlessness. How naturally in these moods one looks back to home and the mother with whom God blessed us : O how deeply. There is nothing to compare with this blessing. One hardly feels as if she were absent : the words of love and forgiveness she spoke in those last solemn hours before she passed into the unseen are still here and fill me with a joy and peace that not even the remembrance of my undutiful- ness can seriously disturb.
In his reply, dated October 8th, Daniel Macmillan endorses what his brother says about home and its recollections and influences being the most precious of possessions, though he has also to reckon amongst these
61
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1854
on Logic and is a favourite of Sir W. Hamilton, were at Smith's rooms one night, and they also promise to see after Brimley. Dobell, too, the author of "Balder" and "The Roman," is a great ally of Smith's, and lives out at Corstorphine with his wife, who is an invalid. I was introduced to him one day on the street, and he expressed a great wish to know George, and said if he liked he would be glad to drive him out to his place one day. . . . George is going on excellently well, and is able to drive out every day. Both Syme and Simpson in speaking of him spoke with the respect and affection he deserves.
On his return journey he paid a visit to his married sister Janet (Mrs. Wilson) at Stewarton, and saw James MacLehose at Glasgow. "He was of course as kind and warm-hearted as ever. . . . His shop filled me with envy." In short, he sums up his Scotch trip as a success in every way. Not less cheerful is the tone of his letter of September 3oth, a red-letter day for the firm:
Kingsley wrote to me to-day, giving me the title of his book. It is "Westward Ho! being the voyages and adventures of Sir Amyas Leigh of Burrough, Co. Devon, in the reign of Queen Elizabeth of glorious memory." A capital title I think.
On October 2nd he alludes to the victory of the Allies at the Alma, and on October 3rd gives an amusing account of his two-year-old son :
To give you any of Malcolm's speeches would require a new system of phonetics. When he does not want to do anything, he says in a most emphatic manner "Bapom (i.e. Malcolm) don't wish." . . . He makes attempts at any sentence you like, m's becoming b's, and 1 being always thrown overboard. He gets very fat and very wilful, likes sugar very much, and has a marvellous good appetite. He has a great fancy for the
60
i854] HOME INFLUENCES
moon, especially when he and I are in a very friendly mood. He looks up in my face and points out of the window and says, "papa, the moon." I don't suppose he means to assert that I am the moon, but that he wants to make me aware of its existence somewhere out in space.
The letter of October 6th strikes a more intimate and serious note :
Your remembrances of our course of life since we came to England should indeed fill us with gratitude and humility and hope. Wonderfully indeed have we been guided and blessed. . . . What do I not owe you, my noble brother, for your patience with my weakness and faults, and for your help and example all these years. God knows, who is the giver of all good gifts and the root of these blessed family ties, and who made that blessed human heart by which indeed we do live really human lives. I am far from being a good man of busi- ness, brother, husband, father or citizen, and yet I feel a power of entering in the blessedness that belongs to all these that gives me hope for myself in spite of all my failings, for it makes me feel that the Spirit of God of order and love is at least striving with me and trying to help me in spite of my worthlessness. How naturally in these moods one looks back to home and the mother with whom God blessed us : O how deeply. There is nothing to compare with this blessing. One hardly feels as if she were absent : the words of love and forgiveness she spoke in those last solemn hours before she passed into the unseen are still here and fill me with a joy and peace that not even the remembrance of my undutiful- ness can seriously disturb.
In his reply, dated October 8th, Daniel Macmillan endorses what his brother says about home and its recollections and influences being the most precious of possessions, though he has also to reckon amongst these
61
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1854
the friendship of such people as the Wilsons, Maurice and others, the books he has read and the experiences given him through his trials and temptations. He then continues :
There is one part of your letter I do not agree with. That is where you speak against yourself. I feel quite sure that you are quite sincere in all you say. At the same time I must say that I don't know and never knew any one who was more unselfish and self-forgetful than you are, or who was kinder or more tender hearted.
He goes on to say that the alteration in position and circumstances do not make one any happier. He would not mind once more going through the trials of his voyage to Scotland in a Leith smack (London to Leith, Dec. 18-25, 1836), or his illness at the Wilsons when they nursed and fed him until he got well and was able to find work. These times were never cheerless. If it were possible and needful, he would not shrink from going over it all again, but,
I could not say that of the years that have passed since our position and circumstances seem to have improved. For instance, I would not go through the year from June, 1853, to June, 1854, for any imaginable prize. . . . You are so much braver and so much more unselfish that it did not afflict you as it did me. Perhaps my ill-health was in part the reason why I felt so keenly what you bore so nobly. But be that as it may, it is quite certain that never in the course of my whole life did I experience so much cruelty, or saw such hollowness or cowardice. That is all over now, thank God!
Alexander Macmillan appreciated this fraternal greet- ing, but demurred to the philosophy set forth in its concluding passages :
62
1 854] COLENSO'S PROPOSAL
October nth, 1854.
Many thanks for your long and most pleasant letter — wise and loving, like yourself. But you must not say that there are not advantages in having larger rooms, better clothing and better food. They do not constitute happiness certainly : indulgence causes misery. But, after all, tight circumstances no more than tight boots are comfortable, and I confess I look forward with much pleasure to the time when everybody shall be in tolerably easy circumstances. It is not to be despised, and the old life is not to be lusted after — any more than the flesh-pots of Egypt.
References to the progress of the Crimean war alternate with domestic and business matters. ' ' There are a good many freshmen about and a few have dropped in, but as yet there is little doing. Books are the last thing the student thinks of." The prospect of his brother's return in a fortnight or so fills him with joy, and on October I4th he reports an interesting proposal from Bishop Colenso :
Bishop Colenso dropped in to-day and asked to have some private talk. It was this : He wants to make up a companion to Holy Communion out of the writings of Mr. Maurice.1 Mr. M. has given his con- sent to the project, and any profits which arise from it are to be devoted to the Bishopric of Natal. He said he thought we would forgo any trade profits ourselves, as he would look on it as a great triumph to be able to make a good round sum out of Mr. Maurice's writings for Missionary purposes. His idea is to make some such book as Wilberforce's Eucharistica. He says, and truly, that the wide circulation of such a book would do a great deal to dissipate the prejudice which so
1 Published in 1855 under the title The Communion Service, from the Book of Common Prayer, with select readings from the writings of the Rev. F. D. Maurice, M.A. Edited by the Right Rev. J. W. Colenso, D.D., Lord Bishop of Natal, and still on sale.
63
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1854
unjustly exists against him, and so do great good to England. For the excellent Bishop is not less enthusi- astic in his admiration of the prophet, and even accepted this designation for him as heartily as any of us less dignified and younger men.
October 2oth, 1854.
I do so deeply feel how envy in any shape and towards any one weakens and degrades. Some people deteriorate more than others under the feeling — I most of anybody, I think. You can hardly imagine what deep peace it gives me when I can get heartily to contemplate the success of others — even of rivals. We ought surely not even to envy those who appear to have a spite against ourselves. God make us unselfish and like Himself! Why should I have indulged in this moral reflection just at present, when I feel rather in a hurry? I am sure I don't know. There it is, however. ... I enclose a prospectus which Furnivall sent me this morning of the new College. He is in great spirits to have got Ruskin.
October 23, 1854.
I did not write yesterday because I was reading the Sermons [Maurice's] all day when I was not other- wise employed. They really are most wonderful, and I should think would cause a stir — certainly they will have a great influence sooner or later. . . .
On the question of the price at which Maurice's Sermons should be offered to the public he held strong views :
Both my partner and myself are still clearly of opinion that the price should not be more — not a penny. It is not merely that it would hinder the sale of the book — that it would do. But it would look terribly greedy and damage both Mr. Maurice and ourselves as pub- lishers. I do feel convinced that the book will sell, and largely too. Many a comparatively poor man will buy it and be edified by it who at the bigger price would
64
1 854] TOM HUGHES'S PROTEST
have had to shake his head and go without it. Half curious and half indifferent people who would rather like to look at it will say No, it is too dear. It is really a Gospel. We can't give it without money and without price — why should we not at least give it at a reasonable price ?
As we have seen, Alexander Macmillan had estab- lished friendly relations with Tom Hughes and his neighbour and friend Ludlow, and a letter in which he addressed Hughes as u Dear Sir " provoked the follow- ing characteristic reply :
The Firs, Wimbledon,
November 9, 1854. Tom Hughes to Alexander Macmillan.
Tom Fool's Day in London.
My dear
What shall I call you bad enough : do you think I am going to stand " My dear Sir" at this time of day from you, why what the good wind can have happened to you, hot-headed Celt ? * Was it for this the conquering Celt of yore." Oh, blow it all — If we had you here in the common room l to-night when I am smoking the unsocial pipe (Ludlow not having turned up) wouldn't we work you! — I am quite consoled at not having written to thank you before for the songs when I turn up your note and find this beginning, which I hadn't noticed before. However, many thanks for the songs ; my missus isn't in playing order just now, but I think I shall like some of them ; I shall make my sister sing them when I can catch her. — Suppose you drop in at 3 Old Square the next time you are up, which you didn't the last time. — The College gallops and the Prophet is in great force of all kinds. — Kind regards to your brother. Ever yours very truly, also Sir — reverently, THOS. HUGHES.
1 Hughes and Ludlow occupied adjoining houses connected by an apartment known as the " common room." E 65
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1855
Alexander Macmillan had now for several years been keenly interested in the social reforms initiated by Maurice and his circle, and he took an active share in the founding of the Cambridge Working Men's College, suggested by the recently established College in London bearing that name. At the preliminary meeting held March 26th, 1855, at which he was present, he said " that he had conferred with several working men, who are anxious to secure education of a different kind from that given in Mechanical Institutes." The list of those present at this meeting, who offered their services as teachers, is worth recording : Rev. Harvey Goodwin (afterwards Bishop of Carlisle), Rev. Augustus Jessopp, Rev. C. B. Hutchinson, Rev. J. B. Lightfoot, Rev. W. W. Howard, G. D. Liveing, J. Lempriere Ham- mond, Rev. C. B. Scott (afterwards Headmaster of Westminster), Rev. H. Latham (afterwards Master of Trinity Hall), Alexander Macmillan, W. A. Porter (a brother of the Master of Peterhouse), H. J. Roby, Rev. J. Fuller, J. B. Mayor, Rev. Fenton J. Hort, F. Gerald Vesey (now Archdeacon), and H. M. Butler (the present Master of Trinity). Other notable names were subsequently added, including those of Clerk Maxwell and John Seeley, who was introduced by Alexander Macmillan — and at the next meeting Alexander, who went to London specially to "get up the details of the College," as he puts it in a letter to his brother, was appointed joint honorary secretary with F. Gerald Vesey. From 1855 to 1858 he regularly attended the meetings of the Council, held on an average once a month, and occasionally acted as chair- man. December I2th, 1859, *s tne date °f n^s ^ast appearance. Mr. Robert Bowes, to whom I am indebted for this information, tells me that the College ultimately
66
i8ss] SUCCESS OF "WESTWARD HO!"
died for lack of students, a curious commentary on the exceptional distinction of the staff. But many of the teachers were most successful in getting into touch with their pupils. Thus, Mr. (afterwards Lord Justice) Rigby enabled a working shoemaker to go to the University, where he took a good place among the Wranglers in the Mathematical Tripos.
On April 1 7th he writes that Mr. Kingsley had sent a letter from Carlyle accompanying one from the editor of the Revue des Deux Mondes asking for a copy of Westward Ho! to review. " I have sent it. I thought on the whole one could hardly refuse." Westward Ho f was doing well, though on April 28th Alexander notes that while Fraser had announced an article on Westward Ho ! in the next number, neither the Times, nor the Guardian, nor the Examiner had yet touched it. Mean- time the best Cambridge critics, including "Clark of Trinity and Professor Thompson," thought highly of it. The Times notice, it may be added, did not appear till August 1 8th.
Kingsley was already at work on Glaucus, and Alexander Macmillan made minute suggestions to him as to the title page and frontispiece. But this, as Mr. Bowes reminds me, was his constant practice. He could not draw himself, but he was full of ideas about bindings, titles, title pages, etc., which his binder, James Burn, and Orrinsmith, the woodcutter (formerly assistant to W. J. Linton and afterwards Burn's partner), loyally carried out. As he shrewdly put it to his brother : 'You don't know the influence of prettiness on even sensible people." At this particular juncture, however, he was not a little hampered by the need of consulting his brother at every turn. Daniel Macmillan, acting on the advice of his excellent Torquay doctor, had
67
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1855
determined to stay there for the summer, and was in a very despondent mood and inclined to discourage all expansion or expense. He talked of reducing his midday meal to a single chop and of rushing home. Alexander Macmillan replied with good humour and good sense: April 30.
Now take two chops to-morrow or I shall think you a goose. I really am doing as well as I know how in every matter. Even though we have not a penny when we die, if we leave boys and girls who can do their work I don't think one need grumble about it — certainly anything is better than that foolish anxiety that could induce you to refrain from eating a chop on any other ground than that you could not digest it.
May ist.
Don't worry yourself and don't be too hard on me. For half an hour after reading your letter to-day I was under the impression that I was a terrible fool. I have been recovering my good opinion of myself by degrees, and at this moment I do seriously think I can get on without greatly damaging the business till your return next October.
This incident is worthy of mention because it is almost the only occasion on which anything approaching friction between the brothers ever showed itself. The little breeze soon blew over, and the correspondence is resumed on terms of unimpaired confidence and affec- tion. On May 6th Alexander expresses regret for his inability to put up with reproof or correction coupled with admiration for his brother's patience and forbear- ance in his enforced idleness. "If it were me, of course being naturally lazy, it would be easy enough to lie still."
The question whether they ought to publish books the tendency of which they personally disproved had
68
1 855] ETHICS OF PUBLISHING
been raised twice over this year, and on both occasions had been decided in the negative, although the authors were men of great ability and their cause had been strenuously and powerfully supported. Now they were confronted with another problem in the ethics of publish- ing. Ought they to issue a book in which incidentally an attack was made on Maurice :
Cambridge, May 9, 1855.
My feeling about R is somewhat the same
as it was about — — [one of the authors whose books
they had declined to publish]. People like
profess to publish anything — to have no prejudices or sympathies in their publishing. We cannot do so — it would not be true to ourselves. I don't think it a right or a manly position. There is no doubt it is a very delicate question where one's interference is to stop- but I really don't think that it is to stop at such a manifest piece of slander as this. Maurice has guarded himself in every way against such a charge,1 and besides, any one with brains, and who used them, must see that his whole theory was utterly opposed to any such mechanical necessitarianism as is implied in such a theory. However, I leave it in your hands. I hope I am not imposing too much on you. . . .
Daniel Macmillan concurred, with the result that an amicable arrangement was made by which the publi- cation was transferred to another firm.
Cambridge, May 26.
I told you hurriedly [in the postscript to his last letter] about Todhunter's eagerness after a literary paper. His notion was for a weekly, or at any rate a fortnightly publication — made, however, rather into a magazine than a newspaper. He says he is determined it shall be done, so if that is the case we might as well
aThat he was a Universalist and denied a day of general judgment.
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1855
have a share in it. My idea is to make a thing like the Revue des Deux Mondes, and call it "The World of Letters." Sir James Stephen was very eagerly advising that we should do something of the kind too. 1 'You have such material here, and it would do your
General business so much good." It really was very ind of the old gentleman. I said the great difficulty in this sort of thing was to find a competent editor. He said, " Suppose an editor found" in a sort of signifi- cant way that had I been in the position to strike a bargain I should certainly have said, "Could you name one?" ... I believe a thing of that kind might be got up to an enormous sale if made tolerably cheap, is. or is. 6d. However, it is a matter of talk after all. I am pleased with my title, "The World of Letters : a Chronicle of Literature."
Daniel Macmillan, in a long and detailed reply, showed that he was opposed, on very good grounds, to their plunging into this scheme, and gave an admirably chosen list of questions to be gone into before a decision could be made. " Do you think," he asks, " Todhunter at all guesses the toil it would involve to do the thing as well as Rintoul does his Spec fa for ? " Alexander Macmillan returned to the charge with suggestions as to the finance, make-up and general character of the proposed journal, but the scheme came to nothing, and in later years he was strongly of opinion that it was best for a publishing firm not to be mixed up with such an undertaking. Daniel Macmillan, in alluding to the matter a few days later, hints that the project of a London house for the firm would be much wiser than that of a literary journal.
Alexander, as may be gathered from the following letter, did not subscribe to the view recently proclaimed by a fashionable philosopher that "our family system has broken down":
70
i855] GLADSTONE'S SPEECH
Cambridge, May 28th.
... It surely is a blessing that God has built us in families and knit us together by natural bonds which we cannot ignore, and not left us to our wayward wills to settle for themselves whom they should love and to whom they should attach themselves. What a terrible thing it would be if we were all by some incon- ceivable process to be tumbled miscellaneously into this world without father, mother, brother, sister, and told to pick our path in life and our friends as we could. Fancy the heartbreaking and blighted affections there would be! We should be caterwauling like midnight cats continually. Melchizedek was no doubt a pleasant old gentleman, but I don't think I envy him. No! Father and mother are very excellent institutions, and brothers too, as I know to my soul's comfort. But the best institution that ever was conceived may be made of precious little worth if one chooses — but I have not merely the institution of brotherhood to be thankful for but a brother, and a very good one too.
On May 3oth Alexander Macmillan wrote in a spirit of gratitude for much needed rain after drought and good news from the seat of war — the capture of Kertch and an important advance of the French on Sebastopol. On war in general he comments as follows :
One feels a little, or rather a great, perplexity about rejoicing in the destruction of one's fellow-creatures, but in this case surely it means rejoicing in the coming of peace. For surely effectually to cripple Russia is to promote peace all over the world. What on earth can Gladstone mean ? His speech was simple mooning — worse than Bright' s or the Peace Society. Did you read it ? It raises even more serious doubts than in his good sense. How a man holding such views as he does could have allowed two great nations to go to war I cannot understand — and it is manifest that a war carried on by a country in that mood must be the most destruc-
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1855
tive of all wars, because the least purposeful. Vacillation in war is destruction. Now, all that the most rabid partisans said about the ruinous effects of the Aberdeen policy appears fair. Gladstone says it is dangerous to humble Russia without weakening her, and therefore he wishes to patch up a peace now. Of course it is, but also, of course, the Allies must weaken her — cut her claws, raze Sebastopol and take the Crimea from her, or they have gone to war for no purpose. Peace made now without effecting anything of this would just do all that Gladstone fears. . . . What can Gladstone mean ? Put not your faith in enlightened men.
Daniel's answer came by return of post :
War cannot be too resolute, but its aim ought to be right and peace and not " our glory." That I thought was the purpose of Gladstone's speech. But he is not infallible, and having so much to do with the mere financial view of things his vision may have got nar- rowed and obscured.
Alexander, writing on June ist, acquiesces in his brother's condemnation of glorying in mere conquest. But that he thinks is a sin Englishmen are not prone to:
It may be, no doubt, that any virtuous feeling or effort may have its dark demon waiting on it ; but to use the temptation to do wrong as an argument to refrain from doing right is to paralyse action in all cases. . . . Cholera reminds us that we should keep ourselves clean, not the less must we try to drive cholera away. . . . My impression, after reading Gladstone's speech care- fully, I confess still is, that it was a case of applying general unquestionable maxims of right wrongly.
In the first days of June Alexander Macmillan went up to London, when he stayed with the Nutts and met and had much talk with Maurice, Kingsley, Ludlow, Furnivall and Hughes. " Hughes is such a nice fellow,
72
1 855] VISITS THE KINGSLEYS
so kind and warm-hearted. It was he who got the article in the Times — which has not appeared yet, but which he says is in type."
On his return he sent a full account of his visit in a letter dated June 5th. After a visit to Ludlow and Hughes and a chat with Furnivall at Ely Place, he describes how he went on to Chelsea and called on the Kingsleys after dinner, making acquaintance not only with Mrs. Kingsley and the children, but with Kingsley's father and mother. Kingsley discussed his plans, talked of doing another modern novel a la Yeast, but not so uncompromising. His wife, whom Macmillan thought both genial and independent, ' ' thought he ought to stick to the historical, but claimed the children's books first and foremost." Mrs. Kingsley was full of wrath against a young High Church parson in Belgravia who had preached a sermon insulting married women, as she interpreted it. Kingsley himself said it deserved a good horse-whipping, and, when Macmillan boldly declared that it did not matter much whether Belgravia held with him or not, seemed to think otherwise :
When I narrated the conversation next night to the Maurices, the Miss Sterlings and Mrs. Maurice almost went into convulsions at my foolish speech as to the insignificance of Belgravia. Kingsley afterwards got talking Carlylese about our wanting a strong despotism, and said he thought we needed to go through the Imperial phase before we were worthy of a free consti- tution, at which I strongly protested, but in vain.
On the Monday he went to see the pictures with Mrs. Nutt, and then on to Ludlow and Hughes :
How deeply Hughes has taken in Maurice! He talks of him just as one likes to hear him talked of. They want me very much to come up and spend a
73
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1855
Sunday with them at Wimbledon, which I must do before the summer is over. It does one good to see and talk with a strong man like Hughes. Both he and Maurice are terribly disgusted with Gladstone. Maurice thinks he will join Bright and the Manchester peace party and get disgusted with them and they with him. He seemed very sad about him.
Returning to Cambridge on the afternoon of June 4th, he went that evening to expound the scheme of the Working Men's College at Barnwell with Vesey, his fellow-secretary :
We had no speechifying: only miscellaneous gossip tending to bring out points which were obscure. It was a very pleasant meeting, and we got 1 8 new names. We have now 67 in all, and we have three more meetings. I have not the least doubt that we shall commence with 100. Mr. Maurice and the rest of them were delighted with our success — could hardly believe it real. There is no doubt that these things will spread and be of great service. But of all things that idea of Mr. Maurice's about the women is the greatest thing I have heard for a long time. To make mothers in the poorer classes familiar with the laws of health so far as they affect their families, in cleanliness, proper food and the like — that is really an immensely important idea. I think a book might be made by some of Mr. Maurice's medical friends that would sell as largely as Soyer's Shilling Cookery. cc Domestic Management in relation to Health and Comfort." What do you think of writing to Mr. Maurice about it ? ... The Eclectic had a review of Westward Ho ! favourable in the main, but accusing him of exaggeration. It is no use their talking ; both Kingsley and his master [Maurice] are too strong for these chaps either to bully, or sneer, or criticise down — mainly strong because in union with the root of all strength.
A succession of meetings in support of the Working Men's College were held in the course of the week, and
74
x8ss] DEATH OF ARCHDEACON HARE
on June 9th Alexander Macmillan reports that their numbers had reached 120.
The first mention of Dr. George Kingsley, father of Mary Kingsley, occurs in Alexander Macmillan's next letter to his brother : Cambridge, June 1 1 th.
Mrs. Kingsley sent me two stories translated from the German by Dr. Kingsley. The author, Paul Heyse, is a new man, and very popular in Germany. I have read these two, and don't wonder at his popu- larity. They are little idyllic pieces, quite different in subject and structure, yet strongly reminding me of George Sand's little pieces. I almost think if Charles would write a preface we might venture on them at half profits. Would you like to see them?
The brothers had sustained a severe loss by the death on January 23rd, 1855, of their great patron and friend, Archdeacon Hare, who advanced the funds which enabled them to start business in Cambridge, and, above all, had introduced them to Maurice. As Daniel Mac- millan wrote in 1853: "If it had not been for your kind help and encouragement, and friendly recom- mendations, I should not have been here, and I should never have been in a position to marry, nor would my brother." Archdeacon Hare's library had been dispersed at his death, and Maurice came down to Cambridge in June to arrange about a number of duplicate copies of his brother-in-law's books which had been sent to Trinity College Library, and which the Trinity authorities wished to return to Mrs. Hare. The Maurices were stopping at the Bull, where Alex- ander Macmillan called on them with George Brimley :
Cambridge, June I5th.
Brimley was leaving next day at i o'clock, so I let him have as much talk as he liked. He was
75
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1855
making a miscellany of wild, vague assertions which Mr. Maurice was receiving and correcting with his usual calm, gentle wisdom. They got from modern men and politics to talk of older — Elizabethan and Jamesian times. On the whole it was very interesting, in spite of poor George's perversity, and latterly in the conver- sation he said some very good things, which Mr. Maurice took up and worked out. It was mainly to the effect that although there seemed flowings and ebbings in human progress on the whole there was general progress, and that when a nation recedes in one respect, there is generally some compensating movement, as, for instance, under Elizabeth there may [have been] and no doubt was greater dignity about the Court, great dignity and power in the foreign policy, yet parliamentary action was crushed by the very greatness of the monarch. Under James, and even fostered by his meanness, the free popular spirit rose up. This was Brimley's view in answer to Maurice's vindication of Kingsley against his attack on him for exaggeration in dealing with the Elizabethan times. Maurice agreed in the main with this assertion, but said there could be no doubt that particular times had certain characteristics widely diffused and a moral character distinguishing them as much as individual men are distinguished. That the meanness of the Stuart court was reflected in the Stuart literature, even as the dignity of the Elizabethan [court] was in its literature, or [that] of the Common- wealth in its.
Next day Alexander Macmillan met Maurice at breakfast with George Brimley, had a long talk with him in the afternoon about the scheme for stereotyping his books — a scheme of which Maurice highly approved, as it held out the prospect of their being sold cheap — and entertained him and Mayor, Vesey and H. M. Butler to dinner. The party was joined after dinner by Lightfoot, Jessopp and others. ' ' One thing is
certain : everybody enjoyed himself greatly, and
76
i8ss] CHAMPIONSHIP OF KINGSLEY
Lightfoot and Mayor were both in to-day saying how much they had been pleased. It is quite evident that Maurice's personal influence is very great." The prospect of the appointment of their friend Scott to Westminster he dismisses as " too good to be true," and his brother's mention of Clerk Maxwell prompts him to say: "Of course I have had my eye on him for years past. Most unquestionable genius, but, like geniuses, wayward. I fancy he will be rather a discoverer than a writer." Daniel Macmillan had suggested that Kingsley should write a satirical novel in which he should appear to recant and glorify Mrs. Grundy. Alexander Macmillan's reply showed that he realised Kingsley' s limitations. "I think," he writes on June 1 6th, "your last scheme plausible, but scarcely quite adapted to Kingsley's genius." This treatment of Mrs. Grundy, he explains, "requires more humour than he has shown himself to possess." But the report that Kingsley would have to give up his Hampshire living, owing to his wife's delicacy, aroused his enthusiastic sympathy: "It would be a pity if he had to depend wholly on his pen. ... It seems a terrible shame that such a man should be in such circumstances, while so many wretched preferment-seekers get on in the Church. God is over all." A hostile review of Westward Ho/ excited him to fury against Kingsley's detractors :
June 19, 1855.
I enclose the Rambler Review of Westward Ho ! . . . Of course they have a repugnance to Mr. Kingsley, and of course they call his Liberalism false. They are a set of lying scoundrels. They are having a series of articles on John Knox and the Scottish Refor- mation which are as virulent and foul-mouthed as you could wish. If they were worth powder and shot
77
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1855
Kingsley might squelch them. I more and more wish there was a journal in existence which was not hide- bound by party religion or stagnating in cold unbelief. These journals have a tremendous influence, with their daily, weekly and monthly iterations. There is nowhere any voice for Maurice or any of his disciples.
Alexander Macmillan, who spent a week at Torquay at the end of June with his brother, was much exercised in mind on his return by an attack on Maurice in Blackwood) which had already fallen foul of Westward
Hof:
July 4, 1855.
That attack in Blackwood is meant to be very damaging, not only to Maurice, but to all the set of thoughtful men like Thackeray, Tennyson, etc. The writer is, I think, going to give a series. There is a certain kind of cleverness in the article and a great deal of arrogant folly. Of course he quite misunderstands and misrepresents Maurice, and the comic, "chaffy" vein is very monstrous when one thinks of the subject and the man. The book chosen is the volume on Sacrifice.
Alexander Macmillan recurs again and again to this attack in the next few days, discussing its authorship — it was diversely attributed to a Dr. M'Farlane, Presby- terian minister at Dunnington, and Dr. Candlish, the well-known Free Church leader — and the best way of answering it. He wished a pamphlet to be written, but who was to write it? "Davies would be too cold and subtle, Kingsley would be too vehement, Maurice himself would sicken at the work." Another notion of his was to take two pages of the advertising sheet of the next number [of Blackwood] and ujust write oneself a few words exposing the chief calumnies." In the end he acquiesced in his brother's saner view, that
78
i8ss] BUSINESS DIFFICULTIES
the attack should be met in Maurice's new preface to his Old Testament Sermons then in the press, or not at all. The question of Archdeacon Hare's biography also exercised him, but "it is no use speaking to Maurice. He is overwhelmed with other matters, and you seem speaking to a man in another world." Paul Heyse's stories were still hanging fire owing to the attitude of their partner. "Because Dr. Ihne never heard his name in Germany he seems indisposed to undertake it. I do really think it would be foolish not to." And again (July I4th) : "I have written to say that I think it won't do for us always to wait until men are celebrities. We ought to have some confidence in our judgment when we 'have the manuscript' before us." The annual stocktaking had taken place and the results were disappointing. In spite of the success of Kingsley's novel the advance in net profit over the previous year was under ^100, while there was an actual falling off in the retail business :
July 19.
After all there is no doubt that we are not doing what we ought with the business. The outgoing of a third partner's share and so much interest cramps us, and keeps up the very evil it inflicts. I do not see any other way of mending matters except either getting
rid of or extending our business so far that we
shall not have too much capital employed.
Daniel Macmillan had already discussed the possi- bility of finding a new partner who had energy, courage and business experience, and would be prepared to take charge of the London branch, but this rara avis was not forthcoming.
A visit to London towards the end of July, when Alexander Macmillan was the guest of the Clays at
79
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1855
Muswell Hill, attended their annual "Wayzgoose" at the Rye House, near Broxbourne, and transacted busi- ness with Nutt, Bain and others, had a pleasant sequel in a flying trip to Eversley, undertaken at the suggestion
of Tom Hughes :
July 26, 1855.
I reached Winchfield about half-past six and had a good five miles walk along a high road that once was very much frequented by mail coaches, and across a heath wild and wonderful — about one-half of each. They were both exceedingly interesting. The road runs through two very nice little villages, Hartley Row and Hartford Bridge, and all the way is very prettily wooded. A peculiarity was that near the villages there stretched on each side of the road for a considerable distance nice grassy commons, dotted with very pretty trees, and frequented by geese and cows and pigs. These planted commons Kingsley told me were, as far as he knew, peculiar to Hampshire. The moor- land road to Eversley strikes off to the left shortly after you pass Hartford bridge. The heath, I think, is one of the most extensive I ever saw, stretching some 10 or 12 miles square, as a kind of tableland dropping suddenly down into richly-wooded valleys on every side. The walk to Eversley goes round a little corner of the moor and you make a slight descent in among some very pretty trees, Scotch fir and oak chiefly, among which lies the Church, Rectory and an adjacent farm-house, and about a quarter of a mile further the village called Eversley Street.
On his arrival, at 8 p.m., Kingsley was out, but the servant offered him some refreshment, and he strolled about the garden and churchyard and down the road towards the village and back again :
I at last subsided on a gate and lit my pipe and enjoyed the exquisite quiet of the evening twilight. A great white owl came flapping over my head, and
80
1 85s] KINGSLEY AT HOME
again all was still. It was now close on nine and my pipe was out, and I descended from my perch and began strolling towards the village again, when I heard voices in the distance, among which I shortly distinguished the parson's well-known alto uttering something about building churches. Presently he was on me, and I had his warm shake of the hand and greeting, "Ah, Aleck, this is too delightful ! " He bade his friend, who seemed like a well-off young farmer, good-night, and we went into the house, where he ordered some supper — cold beef and cold plum pudding and beer. After that we retired to his "little den," as he called it, had much talk and considerable pipes and beer till about half-past twelve, when we went to bed. I had a capital night's rest and a delightful bath, and we got to breakfast about nine o'clock. After breakfast we walked out in the garden, and then the parson, furnishing me with a pair of shooting boots, took me up through a meadow to see some men who were mowing. He had a lot of talk with them in a kindly way, asking of this man's child and that man's wife in a true, human, interested way that they seemed quite to understand and respond to. We then went back to the house. It was about half- past eleven by this time, and he had decided on coming up to London with me, so off we started on my walk of the night before. Over the heath he discoursed to me about the various historical associations connected with places we could see in the distance — how Sir William Cope's house, which we saw peeping through trees over there, had been a castle built by our Scotch James for his son Prince Henry, and how, after his death, he could not endure it any longer and sold it to some nobleman, through whom it had descended to its present owner — how over there was an old Roman camp, and on the other side Alfred had fought the Danes, and similar traditions. Going through the two villages he was accosted by various farmers and butchers and peasants, and had a kindly word of greeting for all.
F 81
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1855
Kingsley returned to town with Macmillan, who sums up the practical results of his visit by saying to his brother, " We shall have a novel from him in the spring if all is well. He says he must hatch his own chickens ; while he is very much obliged to any one who puts eggs under him, he can't always promise the outcome required." When he was in London Alexander Macmillan saw Maud at Moxon's. The publication of a new poem by Tennyson moved him greatly. Mr. Robert Bowes remembers how he put the volume into his pocket and walked out to the village of Coton to read it undisturbed :
July 27, 1855.
The great event of this week has been Maud. I can tell you that in a word. Our sale has been 50 copies. I don't think this very bad for a long vacation day. ... I cannot say what I think of it as a whole, except that the first impression is excessively painful. It begins to dawn on me as a kind of prophetic utter- ance— our selfish griefs and ioys have to be swallowed
i 11-
up in a larger one by this war.
July 30, 1855.
I was reading one of Maurice's sermons last night, else I had intended to have written you. But I found it such a hard job that it took me quite two hours to master, and then I was uncertain about some of the words. But it amply repaid the trouble. ... It really is grand. One wonders what the people mean when they do anything towards Maurice but listen and learn. ... I think we ought to get these copied out into a book in a clean clear hand. ... I told you he had given me fourteen sermons. Mrs. Maurice evi- dently takes care of them, so we may keep our minds easy about this matter. At the same time it would be a great thing to rescue them from the obscurity of his caligraphy.
82
i8ss] IMPRESSIONS OF SPURGEON
On August 2nd he writes to announce the birth of his second son, George, and the pleasure with which both his wife and himself noticed a resemblance to Daniel. On August 4th he asks his brother, " Do you care to see the completion of The Newcomes? It is so beautiful." And on August 9th he records his first impressions of Spurgeon :
Last night I was induced to go over to Shelford to hear a young man of the name of Spurgeon preach, and after we came home William Johnson1 took me to see him. He certainly has the most marvellous gift of eloquence I ever heard. He used in London to fill Exeter Hall, and thousands had to go away without hearing him. After hearing him I really am not sur- prised. There is a curious simple-minded egotism and vanity about him in private. He is a hyper-Calvinist, as he says, but in the preaching it was marvellous like Maurice.
On August loth he describes a visit from Charles Taylor and Pierce Butler, both returned from the Crimea, where Butler had been chaplain from December to June. They reported favourably on the state of the army, but the officers were terribly jaded, and Butler was very unfavourably impressed by the Turks :
It was, he said, a material drawback to the heartiness with which one contemplated the war that the nation we seem to be fighting for is one that the sooner it goes to pieces the better. . . . This really gives a very con- siderable check to one's enthusiasm for the war. . . . Butler is a particularly nice fellow, and his gentle, sensitive yet strong nature gives one great confidence in his testimony.
Visits from Boole, the mathematician and philosopher,
1 William Johnson, who married Mrs. Macmillan's sister, Harriet Brimley.
83
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1855
and Isaac Taylor — "the dear old man with his quaint formal kindly ways " — with regard to the publication of a uniform edition of his works in 17 volumes, were pleasant features of this month, and the firm were con- sidering a proposal to take over the copyright of Archdeacon Hare's works from Parker. The prospects were on the whole brightening, but their partner, who had been in ill-health, was more than usually obstructive, and had actually proposed that they should write to Paul Heyse and offer him £10 for the right of transla- tion if ever he became celebrated!
When to the obstructiveness of their partner anxiety about his wife and his own indisposition came to be added, it is not to be wondered at that Alexander Macmillan betrayed an occasional querulousness in the letters written during this summer. It was indeed mortifying, as he tells his brother, to contrast the view of their power and importance held by men like Boole and Isaac Taylor with the limitations and drawbacks of their actual position. Again, as it was always "a terrible labour" to him to write a letter, he resented Daniel's practice of writing indirectly to clients through his brother. "Here," he says on August 24th, "you have written to Mrs. Hare in an off-hand way two capital letters, but unfortunately they are imbedded in mine in such a way that I cannot use them, and I have hardly any power of adaptation." A trip to Torquay was contemplated but abandoned, Alexander deciding instead to drive over with Mr. Brimley to see his brother, a farmer near Bedford, and on August 29th he describes his trip to St. Neots, Bedford, and the Bunyan country, whence the Brimleys originally came. Daniel's letters from Torquay show that he too was dispirited by their financial position, and in a letter of August 28th
84
1 855] LETTER TO DANIEL
he discusses the possibility of his wife starting a school. But he fully acknowledges how severely his brother had been tried — "When I think, as I often do, how much you have had on your mind and hands for the last six months without any help whatever from me, I wonder how you are able to bear it all" — and Alexander's reply shows a spirit of deep fraternal gratitude and affection :
August 30, 1855.
Your letter to-day ought to be a lesson to me ; if I were not a dull learner it would be. I really feel ashamed when I recall the querulousness of some of my late notes. You must make some allowance for a man with chronic dyspepsia. You can hardly realise — I don't wish you ever should — the utter unreasonableness of a man whose acrid stomach is always getting into his brain and clouding his heart. . . . Nothing has ever struck me with more admiration than the fact that our old countryman John Knox should have done all that he did with a weak stomach constantly tormenting him. The dear old man ! And yet we know that he was most kindly natured, human as ever man was, with the warmest sympathy and the most resolute will, writing and acting and speaking wise and healthful and helpful words and deeds, and bringing — did he not bring a savage and degraded people, by God's help, into some- thing about as noble as the world has ever seen. And here am I, poor spoony individual, allowing my paltry ailments to interfere with the simple, most blessed fulfilment of my common brotherly duty. I felt at first reading of your letter to-day a little annoyed at your complaint of loneliness, but on more careful thinking over it I feel indeed that, so far as I am concerned, it is quite a just complaint. I must just say one thing, not in my own defence, but merely as a simple statement of fact. I have never felt concerning your enforced idle- ness that it was otherwise than the most grievous calamity and trial your active and helpful nature could
85
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1855
undergo, and if I have ever seemed to grumble that I had too much to do, it never has been even a momentary complaint of want of help from you. In the first place, I really have not any more work than I ought to be able easily to do. And in the next place, I never for a moment forget that I owe to you that I am in the position with so little labour to enjoy so many blessings. Are not my position in life with its wonderful pleasures and duties more blessed than pleasures, my wife and the dear results, under God, your gifts to me ?
Writing two days later, he mentions that he has been reading Kingsley's article on Maud in Fraser and Aytoun's in Blackwood. " . . . Maud is not accord- ing to Grundy in any sense seemingly. George Brimley tells me that I am the only one he knows who stands up for it altogether."
Kingsley was at work on The Heroes, and the first instalment came to hand early in September. On September 8th he writes, "I have not got any one to read Kingsley's Myth Book yet, so I am reading it myself" — his usual practice.
September n.
All the Market Hill is filled with small and great boys shouting and letting off rockets for joy of the great victory at Sebastopol.
September 12.
This is a glorious morning, and the sun is clear- ing all mists from the earth. One ought always to be able to live in some such atmosphere if it were not [for] our self-born mists and clouds. Well, here we are to do our duty under whatever sky. But the walk down from Park Terrace in the clear pleasant air has filled me with a sort of material joy deepening down towards a truer and more rooted [happiness]. Do you know, I
86
i8ss] VISIT TO BRIGHTON
do think happiness is very good for people, notwith- standing all that the moralists do aver.
Alexander Macmillan, as we have seen, was an uncom- promising admirer of Maud, and at the request of his friend and brother-in-law, William Johnson, he now undertook to read the poem, with a running commentary of his own, at a meeting of the Cambridge Young Men's Christian Association :
September 13.
I think I shall enjoy it myself, and I have read it so often and had so much talk with Brimley and others about it, that I shall not need to make much preparation for it. ... I mean chiefly to dwell on its moral lessons for daily life and its human and national teachings. But I won't talk much.
In the latter half of September he took his wife down to Brighton for change of air, and both of them greatly profited from the visit. He took, it is true, an active part in assisting the promotion of the proposed Working Men's College at Brighton, but for the most part was content to enjoy the rare pleasure of idleness :
September 26.
The truth is, the last few days were occupied in lying on the beach, varied with a few walks with Henry Johnson, whom I like very much indeed. I did not see any one. I only saw the sea and the sky and the moon. It is very tempting to idleness — perhaps on the whole that is the proper word under the circumstances.
For some time past negotiations had been going on with J. W. Parker with a view to the Macmillans taking over the works of Archdeacon Hare, and on September 28th Alexander Macmillan wrote to his brother to say their offer had been accepted. 'There is no doubt therefore now that we shall have all the excellent Arch-
87
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1856
deacon's books." A week later he forwarded a letter from Kingsley giving an outline of his new novel (Two Tears Ago), " which is quite grand," and adds, " I read Maud last night with applause/' Alexander was look- ing forward with keen pleasure to his brother's return from Torquay — "It will 'yield a dear delight' to have wife and brother at home again" — but within a few days of his return to Cambridge in November Daniel Macmillan suffered a severe relapse, a bitter disappoint- ment to his devoted wife, but borne by him with fortitude and resignation. In other ways the prospect was brighter than it had been for years. The balance sheet for the next year, 1856, was the best the firm had ever known ; and by its close they were relieved from their obstructive partner by an amicable dissolution of partnership. The year opened pleasantly for Alexander with a short visit to London, where he spent a night with Hughes and Ludlow at Wimbledon.
On January i8th Kingsley wrote to say that he was giving up going to Italy, as he could not see the Vaudois valleys without Strettell1 as guide, but he meditated going to Snowdon in August with Hughes, adding : ' ' I can do nothing with Maurice. He always swears
1 Kingsley planned and sent Macmillan a scenario of a novel on the Vaudois Massacre in 1655, but never carried it out. The Rev. Alfred Baker Strettell (1817-1904), for many years Consular Chaplain at Genoa, where he showed true heroism during the cholera epidemic of 1854-5, was an intimate friend of Charles Kingsley and F. D. Maurice. In 1862 he "discovered" San Moritz, where for many summers he acted as Chaplain for the S.P.G. Mr. Strettell, who reckoned Charles Dickens, Tom Hughes, Tom Taylor and many other men of note amongst his friends, was a great walker and fine Alpine climber. He died at Varallo in 1904. There is a memorial window to him in the English Church at San Moritz, which he was largely instrumental in founding, and a pair of carved doors and a tablet in the English Church at Genoa record his connexion with the neighbourhood, where he was long remembered by the peasants as " the good English priest."
88
1856] KINGSLEY ON MICAWBER
that he is quite well, and that he overeats himself and overdrinks, which is three lies, but he must have his way." Kingsley's letters to his publishers are through- out marked by a characteristic boyishness of manner, and agreeably illustrate the friendly relations that pre- vailed between them :
Eversley, May 19, 1856. Charles Kingsley to Alexander Macmillan.
... I wonder whether I shall always be in Mr. Micawber's purgatory— " Income £20 per annum, Expenditure £20 os. ojd., Result total misery " ; or ever attain to his paradise — ''Income £20 per annum, Expenditure £19 195. n^d., Result total felicity"?
Did I tell you that Glaucus seems to have pierced the "august abodes" of Windsor, and to have elicited the present of a handsome book from H.R.H. Prince Albert, not to mention a very kind letter from Lankester, the editor of said book ? Glaucus has certainly got me some dozen or two of introductions to first-rate naturalists, which will be a pleasure to me hence- forth. . . .
May 22, 1856. From the same to the same.
A thousand thanks for your obligingness. You certainly are a most pleasant person to deal with, and please God you will have no reason to regret it.
In July Alexander Macmillan records another full and delightful week in town. Monday night, "dine and sleep" at Wimbledon with Hughes. Tuesday and Wednesday, "talks with Maurice at his new house, 5 Russell Square." On Tuesday night he stayed with Bell at Hampstead, moving on to the Nutts at Surbiton on Thursday, and thence to Eversley to spend a few days with the Kingsleys.
89
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1856
Macmillan's intimacy with Tom Hughes had grown out of their common attachment to Maurice and the cause of social reform. Hughes had taken an active part in the journalistic side of the movement, but until this autumn had given no sign of the special literary talent which was to make him famous.
10 Prospect Place, Deal, Sept. 25, 1856. T. Hughes to Alexander Macmillan.
Dear Mac. How's yourself, and where' s your- self? My chief reason for writing is, that, as I always told you, Pm going to make your fortune, and you'll be happy to hear that the feat is almost or at least more than half done. Pve been and gone and written or got in my head a one vol. novel, a novel for boys, to wit Rugby in Arnold's time. Ludlow is the only cove besides my wife who has seen a word of it, (and mind if you take it or don't I can't afford to have it known) and he thought it would particular do, and urged me to go on with it which I have this vacation and only want the kick on the breech that some cove's saying he would publish would give me to finish it. Shall I send you 3 or 4 chapters as specimens or will you meet me in town next Wednesday, Thursday, Friday or Saturday? Do come up and we'll have a dinner and nox together with baccy and toddy, and I'll tell you all about our Welsh tour. . . . Kindest regards to the frater. Ever yours fraternally
THOS. HUGHES.
Alexander Macmillan was at Brighton with his wife *' in delightful drizzly rainy weather" when he received this letter, and wrote at once to offer himself for a night at Wimbledon. In a couple of months Tom Brown was in the press, the format adopted provoking the following humorous expostulation from the author:
90
1 856] "TOM BROWN"
^ Old Square, Nov. 22, i8c6. Dear Mac,
' Woe unto them that make the homar small and the ephah great (something or other, I've forgot it and the spelling be blowed. You'll find what I mean some- where in Amos, or some other jolly old hard-mouthed prophet) that they may sell the refuse of the wheat." Ours aint refuse, at least we hope not, so why make your page so small and margin so huge as in the proofs you sent me? I hate short measure. What's the use of it here? Pll write any amount of nonsense which you'll publish, so why stint folk of it ? With the present size of type and margin folk will only get about 30 short lines in a page, and it will be too much to see one's schoolboy stories covering such huge lots of paper. Reconsider this point if it can be done without expense. I've corrected the proof and followed all your sugges- tions, putting the Latin in notes and dropping some of my familiarity, but if I'm to write at all it must be as I think and talk which is always in the vernacular and chawbacon way of my native country. I never yet was on stilts, moral, intellectual or physical (no, I lie, on physical I have been) and please God don't ever mean to get there. ... I am going for a day or two to Rugby next week to freshen my memory. . . .
The first suggestion of Macmillan's Magazine is to be found in a letter from J. M. Ludlow in November, 1856. He urges on Alexander Macmillan that not only did the brothers want a London shop, "more West-endian than Bell's or Nutt's," but that they wanted a magazine of their own :
Look at this Tom Brown, first-rate as it is, — I suspect you will still have some difficulty in getting for it all the success it deserves ofF hand, coming from an entirely new author. Now if that same Tom Brown had been published in a magazine, for which it is admirably adapted, not only would it have increased the sale of the magazine largely as it went on, but by the
9*
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1857
time it had got to the end it would no longer be a book by a new hand, — it would on being republished as a whole, just step into success, instead of having to fight its way into it.
Early in December Tom Hughes' s children were struck down by scarlet fever ; his eldest girl died, and he himself was so broken by his loss that for the moment he had not the heart to complete his story. Indeed Ludlow actually wrote to Alexander Macmillan suggest- ing that the book should be published as a fragment or that they should get Hansard (the Rev. Septimus Hansard), another good ' ' Arnoldian," to finish it. Happily there was no need to resort to such measures. Hughes regained his courage and finished the book, which was brought out — anonymously at first — on April 24th, 1857, and achieved an immediate and resounding success.
Meantime Charles Kingsley, invigorated by his summer holiday in North Wales, was working with immense energy at Two Tears Ago. On November 4th, 1856, in announcing the title, he says that he has written about half : " the rest is in my head. Froude has read a good deal of it, and his opinion is far more hopeful than I could have expected, and has given me quite new courage." A month later he reports rapid progress, but * ' what with the book and the parish I never was so hard worked in my life. I have two or three dying people on my hands, besides the usual work, but I am wonderfully well and my brain, thank God, as clear as a bell." The book was finished with a rush by the end of the year, and on January 9, 1857, all the proofs were returned except the introductory chapter. Even Kingsley himself realised that he had been going too hard and must take a rest :
92
i857] KINGSLEY ON REALISM
Eversley, January 26/57. Charles Kingsley to Daniel Macmillan.
Anent your plan of a common life novel. Yours is very admirable, and good as notes to think over. But it will be long ere I write another. Cer- tainly not for a couple of years. Two Tears Ago is as near common life as I care to get. My great complaint of the book is, that it is so much more tame than common life really is. The fault of the usual common life novels is their execrable goody-goody-ness, — the insipid respectability (utterly untrue to life) of their personages, who make up for want of character and want of action by endless analysis of little dirty common- place motives. Let us leave all that to the authoress of Squeeky, The Narrow, Narrow World, and The Hills of the Chattermuch, with the rest of the American twaddlers, male and female, who are deluging the world with pictures of American respectability — as false to fact as possible. I suppose they are drawing an ideal, what they would like to see America ; they certainly are not drawing what she is. And I, if I went in the general rut, should not be drawing England as she is — though we have no slaves!
Let me go on, doing what I have always done, from Teast and Alton Locke till now ; shewing how much of the heroical and tragical element, supposed to be dead, buried, and whitewashed over, survives in modern society, ready to reassert itself for evil and for good the moment a great cause or a great sorrow appears. I am the prophet of the coming convulsion ; I cannot cry peace, peace where there is none. I see all things in Christendom drifting toward the hurricane-circle of God's wrath and purifying storms. I can only tell people that, again and again, in every possible form, and say, "While you are believing in hell, you are forget- ting God ; and in saving yourselves out of hell you are blind to the fact that you are rushing upon the thunder- bolts of God himself. Cease to do evil, learn to do well ; learn what this world means, and what God is
93
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1857
doing here ; and then only it will be time to talk about the world to come, and what He will do there.
Writing a few days later about the alterations in the new edition of Westward Ho ! Kingsley mentions his readiness to defer to the judgment of George Brimley, and notes that Thackeray thought the first volume " too prolix." He hoped Macmillan's sanguine anticipations about Two Tears Ago would be fulfilled, but adds : " I don't coincide in them. We shan't get a Times review on account of Parliament, and the Saturday will surely snub us, as will the Athenaeum^ which hateth me with a perfect hatred."
If Kingsley had misgivings about the reception of Two Tears Ago he had none about Tom Brown's Schooldays, which he had been reading in proof :
Eversley, February 14, 1857. Charles Kingsley to Daniel Macmillan.
... If you do not push that book of Tom Hughes's, why then I shall set you down for no Scot. For why? It will be a very great hit. It is an extra- ordinary book. Take it all in all, you won't see such smart writing, such knowledge of slang and all manner of odds and ends, combined with the actual knowledge of boys, and with the really lofty tone of religion and the broad humanity, in any living writer. Beside, it is the only book of its kind. I should have been proud to have written that book, word for word as it stands. In point of art, perhaps, the first cap. is too long. It will not catch boys' minds immediately enough, and serve as a keystone to the whole ; which is important. But if that book does not have a huge sale at public schools and railways, then am I an ass, or else the world is. I'd have tried to make terms with the Yankees. As sure as you live, the book will be pirated in America, and have an awful sale. . . . Also, Tutor Brice, who
94
1 85?] KINGSLEY ON "TOM BROWN"
has been in Australia, voweth that it would sell largely there. As sure as eggs are eggs the book will pay both of you well. I only wish a few "dammes" had been left out. Folks are mealy-mouthed hypocrites at best. If there is time, I'd erase (or cancel even) them. I feel strongly about that, so think over it.
But oh ! I have laughed and cried over the book to my heart's content. Funny bits of it are worthy of Lever, and serious bits of it worthy of — I can't say whom.
No one rejoiced more in the success of Tom Brown than Kingsley. A few months later he writes: "I am glorified at Tom Brown his glory. A fast hunting man said to me in the field the other day, * If I had had such a book when I was a boy, I should be a better man now,' and two or three redcoats murmured assent." Mean- time 'Two Tears Ago had evoked all manner of gratify- ing tributes in the press and elsewhere. Froude wrote to Mrs. Kingsley: "Charles has written his best book and all the world knows it," and Mudie told Froude that he thought Kingsley would like his criticism on his book — an order for 1000 copies.
Mrs. Dyer, Alexander Macmillan's eldest daughter, observes that " the most vivid impression on our young minds was made by Charles Kingsley, perhaps the most loved of all my father's friends, as Mr. Maurice was the most revered. His romantic appearance, the keen eagle- like face lighted up by those wonderful blue eyes, the elaborate courtliness of his manner, his boyish spirits, his delightful talk of outdoor things, the impetuosity of his utterance, which was emphasised by his stammer ; all deeply impressed the childish mind." Kingsley's side of the question is shown in repeated acknowledgments of the liberal treatment of his publishers. "You have in all ways behaved like, what you and your brother
95
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1857
are, generous gentlemanlike men" (April 4, 1857), and he recurs to the subject on April I3th :
Charles Kingsley to Daniel Macmillan.
What with two services, sermon, private com- munion, and the usual parish work, daily, this week, in addition to the company of the loveliest angel of a niece, I have been so busy that I have not had time to write letters, not even to you ; but being safely out of church, and my Easter sermon about half cooked, I find time during baccy to thank you for your most kind letter. I am so addled with continual extempore preaching (the hardest human work, save to a shameless Irishman) that I can't pay compliments, or even be grateful : but you are two good fellows, and that's enough.
... I have in petto for next Xmas " My Boy's Book," which will be discussed with you in due time. . . .
Cambridge has been miserably beaten at Putney, all owing to that waterman's trick of shoving their oars into their laps, which Louie Denman1 introduced in my time, and which I always hated. We have not been so beaten for years, and I am sulky as a bear. However, it is a wholesome lesson.
The year 1857 brought increased prosperity to the firm. It was also clouded by an irremediable loss in the
1The Hon. Lewis W. Denman, brother of the judge, who rowed No. 2 in the Cambridge crews of 1841 (victorious), and 1842 (defeated) against Oxford from Westminster to Putney. He was ordained in 1844, was successively Rector of Washington, Durham and Willian, Hitchin, Herts, and died May 6, 1907. In the early *' seventies," and for many years afterwards, he used to come to Cambridge from time to time to coach the Magdalene College crews. Mr. Rudolph C. Lehmann, to whom I am indebted for this information, tells me that the race of 1857, of which Kingsley speaks, was the first University race in which the crews used keelless boats and round-loomed oars. Cambridge had won in 1856, and they won again in 1858, but in the three races immediately preceding 1856 Oxford had won.
96
1 85 7] DEATH OF DANIEL MACMILLAN
death of Daniel Macmillan. In the late autumn of 1856 he had returned to Cambridge for the last time, and, as Tom Hughes's Memoir proves, his mind had never been clearer or more vigorous than in the early months of 1857. But in May his strength was sapped by an attack of pleurisy, and after long suffering, endured with wonderful patience, he passed away at the early age of forty-four on the 2jth of June. The peculiar nature of the bond which united the two brothers has been amply revealed in their correspondence, and the sever- ance, though long foreseen, ended a chapter in Alexander Macmillan's life on which he never looked back without reverent acknowledgment of what he owed, under God, to " the best and noblest of brothers," his " partner and guide" for fourteen years. His devotion to the memory of Daniel Macmillan impressed all his friends. Dr. Sebastian Evans illustrates it vividly in his striking paper of reminiscences, and the late Mr. Lowes Dickin- son told me that he regarded it as the leading trait in Alexander Macmillan's character. The practical way in which he construed his obligation is best expressed in his own words. Writing to an old school friend in 1870, he says : " Since Daniel's death over thirteen years ago, his children have been mine. His widow, an excellent and wise woman, lived with me and my wife till about four years since, when she died. Now his three sons and one daughter are as my own children." An act which some would have pronounced exceptionally generous was to him the most obvious and natural thing in the world.
Shortly after I was entrusted with the task of com- piling this memoir, I had the good fortune to spend a few days at Canterbury with the late Dr. Sebastian Evans, one of the closest friends of Alexander G 97
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1851
Macmillan in the middle period of his residence in Cambridge. With characteristic generosity Dr. Evans placed at my disposal the following remarkable apprecia- tion of his friend, which, dealing as it does mainly with the period when Daniel was still alive, serves far better than any words of mine to conclude and sum up this stage of the narrative :
'It was some time early in 1851 that I first made acquaintance with Alexander Macmillan and his elder brother Daniel. I had gone into the shop in company with a college friend who was desirous of consulting Daniel with regard to a projected translation of some then new work by Auguste Comte ; and while my companion and Daniel were closeted somewhere out of sight in the background, I amused myself with taking down from a shelf near the door a most desirable copy of Berthelet's edition of Gower's Confessio Amantis^ a book at that time known to me only by name. I was deep in the story of Rosiphele, the King's daughter of Armenye, when I became conscious of a presence beside me lean- ing forward to look over the book. I turned and my eyes met those of Alec Macmillan. ' Ye love the black letter?" he asked in the sweetest of Scots Doric. "Yes," I answered, "I am fond of the old type, but this story is worth telling in any letters, black, Roman, or italics." Evidently this was a view of the volume which had not occurred to him, and we eyed each other tentatively, much as a Scots collie and a dachshund puppy might on a first casual meeting, both desirous of manifesting good will, but each a little uncertain how his advances might be received. The mutual scrutiny at once established a certain amount of mutual con- fidence, and my mention of Joseph Power, then
98
1851] A TALK AT TRINITY STREET
University librarian, as a friend who had shown kind- ness towards me in my pre-undergraduate days, was gladly accepted as a favourable introduction. We were busy in conversation about early editions of Gowerwhen Daniel Macmillan and my friend emerged from the background and joined us, the latter rather sore and discomfited by the final but friendly rejection of his suggested translation of the French philosopher's latest revelation, and still more by the opprobrious terms applied by the kindly publisher to his intellectual idol. " Here," said the young Comtist, after I had been duly introduced, or rather presented, to the elder brother, "here is this excellent revolutionary publisher who is for enlightening the intellect of England on Scottish Broad-Church principles, telling me that Comte is a crack-brained, ungrateful, sensualistic dreamer! Oughtn't he to be brought in felo de se by a British jury just to encourage other purveyors of benighted literature ? " Then the gentle Daniel took up his parable : "And here," said he, " is a young regenerator of science and philosophy who lives all by himself in a fools' paradise of three hundred years hence, and gets into a fine frenzy of compassion as he looks down backwards upon the noblest workers of to-day." "Yes," said Alec, laying a hand upon my shoulder, "and here is another young philosopher who also lives all by himself in a world of three hundred years ago, and is half disposed to question whether we have made much progress since except in the department of machinery. Don't you think it might be well if both of them were to come, one of them backward and the other forward into the actual present work-a-day world, and do what they can to help us?" So we talked, half in jest and all in earnest, till it was time for me to go back to
99
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1851-
hall " at College — Emmanuel in those days still dining at four in the afternoon — and I returned to my rooms the proud possessor of Berthelet's Gower, which still abides with me and keeps fresh the memory of my first meeting with the brothers Macmillan.
' Such was the beginning of a warm and intimate friendship of which I retain many other pleasant remem- brances, but none so deep and lasting. After more than half a century, the impression still remains indelible. Both brothers had a real " genius for faithful friendship" which never failed : both were in an exceptional degree lovable and true, but if Daniel's always seemed to me the deeper and more commanding nature, Alec's was keener in perception and more spontaneously sympa- thetic. The personal charm of both was magnetic, and this I think it was rather than any supremacy of intellect or force of character that enabled them to exercise a wholesome and stimulating influence over so many of their contemporaries besides myself. The death of Daniel in 1857, grievous as was the loss, seemed not only to develop a hitherto latent strength of will in his brother, but to invest his life for years with something of the spirit of a kindly religious fanatic, who felt that he had a sacred mission laid upon him to perform. In that year, however, I left London, and thenceforward, although I not unfrequently met him and occasionally stayed a night or two at his house, our intimacy — though not our friendship — was broken and discon- tinuous. Still, whenever we met without hindrance in after days, "you knew my brother" was always the pass-word which opened the doors of our former fellow- ship almost as if he regarded the fact as conferring a right on my part to know his inner thoughts and feelings without reserve. The last of such heart-to-heart talks
IOO
1859] RELIGIOUS DIVERGENCES
that I remember with any distinctness had reference to the mysterious disappearance on Mount Olympus of his eldest son Malcolm in July, 1889. He was sorely crushed by the blow, and tears were in his eyes as he told the details of the sad story. When it came to an end, he lay back in his easy chair and said wearily : "I keep on wondering what Daniel thinks of it all." There was a personal appeal to me in the voice, but it was one to which no answer was possible. For in fact, my disbelief in any dogmatic theology had always been a very sore point with him, and at such a moment to feel that my affection for him, eager as I was to speak a word to lighten his sorrow, could offer no sympathy based on religious belief, was an added bitterness which I would gladly have spared him.
1 Our differences on this point, as may be seen from his letter to me of Novr. 16, 1859 (see infra, p. 138), were of long standing. At that time, as his letter shows, he regarded my opinions as virtually subversive of all morality as well as religious faith, and although long before his son's death, he had seen reason to modify his conclusions on this point, his profoundly God-fearing nature was in revolt to the last against what he held to be "the hopeless philosophy." Each of us for the moment had jarred upon the other's limitations, and in the direction of his speculations at least there could be no further walking together.
4 In any "appreciation" of Alec Macmillan and his day's work that I have seen, I have failed to find any notice of what seems and always has seemed to me his most remarkable practical achievement. Speaking from a purely objective point of view, it would be hard to name any one of his generation to whom the Church of England as a national institution owes a deeper debt
101
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1859
of gratitude. At the time he and his brother began to be known in Cambridge, the decadence of the " Oxford movement " had already advanced by leaps and bounds, while the earlier Evangelical movement of which Charles Simeon at Cambridge had so long been one of the most distinguished leaders, had become in the hands of Carus little more than a fatuous travesty of former enthusiasm. An intellectual renaissance of some sort in the Church was imperative if it was to retain its hold upon the people. An extensive and influential if partial renais- sance came in the form of what a little later was known as the " Broad Church" movement, of which a vigorous offshoot was both applauded and reviled as "muscular Christianity." Of this movement F. D. Maurice was the best known and perhaps most popular leader, and of F. D. Maurice, Alec Macmillan was the most enthusi- astic admirer and exponent. He always spoke of Maurice as "The Prophet," one whom "on this side idolatry" he could hardly enough revere. Charles Kingsley too, was one for whom he had scarce less veneration, and even a warmer personal affection. But Alec, like other sensible men, had an intense antipathy to labels, which, as he often said, tell you no more of the man labelled than the fancy title of a novel tells you of its contents and quality. He was almost always labelled and catalogued as a Broad Church man, and, as far as it went, the description was not inaccurate, for his sympathies and general tendencies were rather with that party in the church than with any other. But the description was none the less misleading because it was not inaccurate. He was differentiated from the Broad- Church party as represented by its English leaders, who had plenty of minor differences, individual and other, amongst themselves, by the broad distinction of
102
1859] SYMPATHY WITH CARLYLE
being a Scotsman first of all before being a Churchman of any party. Scottish puritanism ran in the blood of him. John Knox, indeed, would, I fancy, in Alec's mental calendar of saints, have taken precedence even of St. Andrew, and although he declined to accept the doctrine that any of his fellow-countrymen are physically the lineal descendants of the lost tribes of Israel, he certainly regarded the Covenanters as in some sort a chosen people of the Lord. Here, in fact, he was in closer sympathy with the intangible puritanism of Thomas Carlyle than with any Church or party in the Church. With him, Carlyle was an Immortal. Maurice, "prophet" as he was, he regarded as entrusted with a mission to expound Carlyle's profoundly nebulous religiosities to an unbelieving generation in a more systematic and intelligible form. "Matt," stammered Charles Kingsley to Matthew Arnold at one of the Thursday evening gatherings in Bedford St., "Alec strongly suspects Tommy Carlyle of being a deeper humourist than Dante." Arnold snorted, and smiled grimly, but said nothing. The quip was true. Alec looked upon what he called Carlyle's "message to man- kind" as a revelation of permanent interest, which it would be the task of seers in after ages to interpret and act upon as the needs of their own times might demand. It is difficult in these days to realize the extraordinary influence exercised on more than one generation of Englishmen by Carlyle, and more especi- ally perhaps on the Broad Church circle of which the brothers Macmillan, and later Alec Macmillan, were the intellectual centres. It was a wide circle and embraced not a few notable men equal or superior to the brothers in intellect, some with a considerable personal following of their own. In all or nearly all such cases, the bond
103
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1851-
of union was one of opinion and conviction. Maurice's personal following, for instance, was composed mainly of friends and admirers who regarded themselves as more or less disciples, and Maurice as their master. In the Macmillan circle the bond of union was one of general sympathy in all high endeavour. There were no disciples and no master. The school, if it can be called a school at all, was automatically eclectic. Huxley and Bishop Wilberforce might collide explosively at a meeting of the British Association — both shook hands with the Macmillans as friends, not so much of the publishers but of the men. Indeed, had the man of science met the man of religion on the neutral ground of a Thursday evening "Round Table," I have little doubt that they would have shaken hands without misgiving.
* It was just this Scottish and Carlylian earnestness of purpose and no less earnest sympathy with every genuine effort in what he regarded as the right direction which enabled Alec Macmillan to render what to me as an outsider seem to be invaluable services to the national Church. In the forgotten controversies of those days he was always a warm — sometimes, as became a true Scot, a perfervid — partisan both in conversation and private correspondence, but whether, as in the case of the Ecce Homo of the then Professor Seeley, he championed the cause of the writer against all comers, or as in the cases of Bishop Colenso and the contributors to the savagely debated Essays and Reviews, he bore "faithful" witness against the "erring" theologians, he never failed to do justice to the motives of his opponents. He might detest their principles and doc- trines with his whole heart, but his denunciations were impersonal, and he was always ready to admit that his
104
i864] PACIFIC INTERVENTIONS
adversary might be as good a man as himself, or even better than he.
'Essays and Reviews for instance was stigmatised by Alec as a "horrible book," but his personal regard for Dr. Temple, afterwards Archbishop, remained altogether unimpaired. His influence, indeed, on more than one or two occasions within my remembrance, was of very material assistance in allaying bitterness in controversy, in suppressing before they were made public angry words written in haste and heat by ecclesiastical pugi- lists, in summary interdiction of imputing questionable or evil motives. He was not always successful, as for instance in the rapier v. broad-sword duel between Newman and Charles Kingsley, but the case was in many ways exceptional. In every other that I remem- ber, his efforts were more successful. This pacific intervention, however, although often of singular value, was far from being the only or the principal service he rendered to the Church. Characteristic differences have existed from time immemorial between Cambridge and Oxford in the relations existing between teachers and students. During my undergraduateship at Emmanuel, not a single one of my supposed instructors from first to last ever betrayed the faintest indication of any interest in me personally. None of them so far as I remember ever came into my rooms whether I ' ' kept " in College as I did for the first year, or in lodgings as afterwards, except, indeed, on one or two occa- sions, the dean, for the purpose of administering a wigging.
1 Once in the year we were invited to "take wine" with the Master between "hall" ending at five and "chapel" beginning at six, and once in every term with the tutor ; and these functions afforded our sole
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1851-
opportunities of what was called "social intercourse" with those dignitaries. Among the University Pro- fessors whose lectures I attended, Adam Sedgwick was the only one from whom I really learnt anything worth learning. Blunt was fiery and impulsive, but always kindly ; Corrie, then the new Master of Jesus, humorous and patronizing ; Sir James Stephen, polite, but crusty. Outside these, I casually learnt much through my old friendship with Power, the University Librarian, at whose rooms I first made acquaintance with his future successor, Bradshaw of King's, then an undergraduate in my own year. I record these autobiographic details because, mutatis mutandis, they are part of the history of the average Cambridge undergraduate of those days, and are so far material in explaining not only the nature of my own intercourse with Alec, but the nature of what I hold to have been one of the most fruitful labours of his life. It is true that at some of the other colleges the gulf between teachers and taught was by no means so wide. Some of the heads, some of the tutors, some of the resident fellows and professors were in far closer touch with the undergraduates, of whom a considerable number found it possible to regard them more or less in loco parentis, or at least as helpers, friends, and advisers to whom it was always possible to appeal. The men of light and leading in the College were few, and so far as the ordinary undergraduates were concerned, they neither lighted nor led. Guidance and supervision were non-existent. "Coaches" there were, of course, expert in pumping paying instruction into their "pups" for "little-go" and "great-go," but beyond this, the "university education" was left almost entirely to the undergraduates themselves to be gathered as they best might in this, that or the other "set,"
106
1855] INFLUENCE ON UNDERGRADUATES
which they might find most congenial to themselves. For some of us this sort of go-as-you-please independ- ence was probably wholesomer and more stimulating than the stricter restraint of the contemporary system at Oxford, but it left everything to be desired in the way of intellectual training and equipment for the battle of life. Most of the students socially belonging to the middle class went up to college as a necessary preliminary to entering holy orders. It was among these candidates for future ordination that I regard Alec's influence as having been at once most powerfully and most beneficially exercised. Here was a born teacher and preacher about a dozen years older than themselves, a man of striking and varied gifts, of shrewd insight and large experience, always sympathetically interested in younger men at the outset of life who came to him for intellectual guidance and help, — a sort of nineteenth century St. Philip Neri
" always piously inclined To give to youth a sober turn of mind "
and something more — to start it on Broad-Church lines in the direction of "the noble life," his own continual watchword and aim. For many a year after I had left Cambridge, in listening to a preacher unknown to me, his use of some tell-tale catch-word or turn of thought would identify him to me as having at some time or other come under Macmillan's influence, and more than once or twice I was afterwards able to verify my inference.
* At our universities, a generation is considerably less than a lustrum, and a graduate returning to Oxford or Cambridge to take even his Master's degree is apt to find himself already a Rip Van Winkle in his old surroundings. Between the first settlement of the
107
ALEXANDER MACMILLAN [1851-
Macmillan brothers at Cambridge and the migration of Alec to London, several thousand undergraduates had joined the ranks of the English clergy. Of this number, a large proportion of the more earnest and exemplary owed much of whatever strength of character and practical religion they possessed to Macmillan's teaching and example. In one of his Divinity lectures, I remember Professor Corrie telling us how "calls to the ministry " were of many different kinds. * * For instance," said he, "in certain circumstances, the pros- pective possession of a family living may legitimately be regarded as constituting such a call." I came straight from the lecture-room, and repeated to Macmillan what he had said, asking whether any circumstances of the kind could rightly be regarded as constituting a call to the ministry? Alec thought for a little while before answering, for he knew that the professor's remark came straight to my address, and then said : "No. It might be a temptation, but it could never be a call. But the dear good man wasn't just thinking of what he was saying." On another occasion, when I had to get up Paley's Evidences for an examination, I asked Alec whether the first words of the book, ' ' I deem it unnecessary to prove that mankind stands in need of a revelation," did not virtually knock the bottom out of all that followed. ' ' Logically, it may be so," he answered, ' ' for I know nothing about logic and not much more of Paley, but with the Great Example before